Poll: The weakest 80's Maiden album?

What's the weakest 80's Maiden album?

  • Total voters
    75
Nah, Sea Of Madness is the weakest, Stranger is my second least favorite :D

HCW is filled with great melodies and the entire middle section is awesome.
Deja Vu is one of their best rockers.
TLOTLDR might have bad lyrics, but the song itself is one of their best for the entire 80s and my favorite song on SIT.
Alex has shitty lyrics as well, but does a lot of interesting things musically.

SOM on the other hand has an annoying main riff with some of the most obnoxious vocal lines in a Maiden song (imo of course). Never cared for Stranger's chorus/main riff either.

And yeah, VXI is awesome :D
 
Vaenyr said:
HCW is filled with great melodies and the entire middle section is awesome.
TLOTLDR might have bad lyrics, but the song itself is one of their best for the entire 80s and my favorite song on SIT.
Alex has shitty lyrics as well, but does a lot of interesting things musically.
Click to expand...
Couldn't agree more with these takes. Especially TLOTLDR (my favorite tune on par with WY) and how the boring history lesson lyrics shave a bit of Alexander's charm (despite musically being one hell of a tune).
Vaenyr said:
SOM on the other hand has an annoying main riff with some of the most obnoxious vocal lines in a Maiden song (imo of course).
Click to expand...
Now this is where we disagree. Absolute monster of a song IMO. Heavy as hell and yes, the mid section is pure gold.
Vaenyr said:
Never cared for Stranger's chorus/main riff either.
Click to expand...
Also love it... yet perhaps one of the ones I fancy less among the pack.

In my book SIT, SSOASS and Powerslave have nothing but kick ass material. And POM would be the same if they dropped QFF (and TBH I consider Sun and Steel to be merely good).
 
Last edited:
karljant said:
And POM would be the same if they dropped QFF (and TBH I consider Sun and Steel to be merely good).
Click to expand...
Funnily enough QFF is similar to TLOTLDR for me in the sense that I ignore the goofy lyrics and appreciate the music and melodies. I absolutely adore its instrumental section, and the guitar tone for the solos in particular is just glorious. One of my favorites on POM because of that!

Sun And Steel on the other hand has some cool ideas, but the chorus is a bit too annoying and happy-go-lucky for my tastes.
 
Vaenyr said:
the chorus is a bit too annoying and happy-go-lucky for my tastes
Click to expand...
Yup... it's exactly the only thing I dislike.

Vaenyr said:
Funnily enough QFF is similar to TLOTLDR for me in the sense that I ignore the goofy lyrics and appreciate the music and melodies. I absolutely adore its instrumental section, and the guitar tone for the solos in particular is just glorious.
Click to expand...
Here's where our tastes differ. I also like QFF's instrumental, and (like anyone else, I hope) also think the lyrics are crap. Now, when it comes to TLOTLDR's lyrics, while far from top tier poetry, it doesn't annoy me the least. Yet, where I think there's a huge chasm between the two tracks is Bruce's choice of melody. TLOTLDR's IMO is easily one of my top 10 Bruce vocal performances (and also a top 10 Maiden song), yet I utterly detest QFF's vocals: the falsettos, the jig like feel... man it just doesn't add up as far as I'm concerned. I wrote this when commenting POM: were the band to make a short instrumental out of QFF filled with harmonies and solos, it would certainly be one hell of a song!
 
karljant said:
"Weakest" and HCW in the same sentence is unthinkable in my book. 10 ou of 10 even with a somewhat repetitive chorus. Which is a trait common to other fan favorites: Deja Vu, Fear Of The Dark, SSOASS, The Wicker Man, Brave New World, Blood Brothers and For The Greater Good Of God (just to name some), and IMO none of them lose their charm despite that aspect.
Click to expand...
Deja Vu a fan fave? That's news to me. Mind you, for me it is a fave indeed. One of my all time fave Maiden tracks. But that's a rare thing, the song is often regarded as filler. I wish it would get the praise it deserves.

Repetitive choruses are the achilles heel of modern Maiden (read post reunion). There were some repeat-lines-over-and-over choruses on early albums too, but they were a minority and even then, the lines each differed a little. In Deja Vu, the chorus lines are not exactly identical, the differ slightly in every second line.
On post reunion Maiden albums, they are usually exactly identical, and that's not the exception, it's the standard. Plus, the vocals often simply follow the guitar melody to make it even more repititive. In many post reunion Maiden songs, the chorus is the weakest part of the track. Different World is a perfect example. Great song, but the chorus really drags it down.
It is a development that really came to be with VXI and existed ever since.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top