Shadow said:
Like The Dark Knight, I found The Prestige to be good but uneven. I disliked the way they brought "real" magic into it towards the end, as the best part of the film so far had been the feeling that all the events had a natural explanation, but you didn't know what. I actually felt a bit cheated by the ending; I like a good SF story, but please tell me about it beforehand.
I've noticed that some some people don't like to be surprised. On the otherhand, I do not like to know too much of a story beforehand, unless the content really interests me (e.g.
Soldaat van Oranje) or when I just happen to know the book years before the film came out (e.g. LOTR).
I had no problem with the real magic. Earlier in the film it was neatly introduced by Tesla, greatly portraited by David Bowie. It thought that it was interesting that the Bale character actually beat the real magic by using a "simple" trick. To follow this trick while watching the film for the second time is quite cool.
I admit that I hoped that the other character would win this competition, so I felt really sorry for him.
Shadow said:
So if I had to choose between the two magician films of 2006, I'd almost be inclined to go for The Illusionist.
I liked that one as well, but the competition element in
The Prestige I found more exciting. The obsessive eagerness of those characters, trying to find out each others tricks.