Recently I have been watching the British television drama Midsomer Murders, about fictional Detective Chief Inspector Tom Barnaby and how he solves many mysterious murders in the county of Midsomer. Of course, the entire premise is fictional, as there is no Midsomer County, and with the amount of murders that happen in the county, certainly the detective would have long ago lost his job.
Tom Barnaby is presented as England's answer to Hercule Poirot in many ways. The two follow similar schemes of detection with an emphasis on intellectual work and analyzing the character of the suspects. Physical violence is almost never directly experienced by Barnaby in the course of his work, though he usually has a younger Detective Sergeant with him to assist in such situations.
Though in the majority of situations, Barnaby captures a criminal and sends them off to prison, like Poirot, Barnaby occasionally is defeated by an enemy, which usually ends up in that person's death or suicide before he can realize the truth behind the crime. Once or twice, Barnaby has let a murderer go - usually because he realizes the evidence against them is either so aged or so thin that the arrest has no chance of going anywhere.
The really interesting aspect of the series is how every episode (each of which is appx. 2 hrs long) seems to display another picturesque village in the English countryside, and how during the course of the investigation, DCI Barnaby and his sidekick discover deviance, corruption, fraud, and philandering behind the "perfect" mask the area wears. In this, it seems the entire focus of the show is social commentary on the people who try to live a life defined by social class (which is very prevalent in Midsomer County) and appearances (even more prevalent). Among the many scandals uncovered by Barnaby in his time include a homosexual relationship between two parish priests, the systematic sexual abuse of a young man by his teacher, an accidental killing of a young boy by a series of pranking teens, and any number of blackmailings and extramarital affairs.
One must remember that it is a TV series and, thus, does not enjoy the luxury of strong actors outside of the main crew, nor of expensive budgets. This makes the series very down to earth when you compare to American crime drama like CSI or even Law and Order. The emphasis is on the abilty of DCI Barnaby and his companion to investigate by asking questions and the basest studies of clues. What few lab tests are used oft occur offscreen, with a phone call or report to the main characters giving them a new direction to travel in. After spending the last decade submerged by CSI and its cohorts of clones, designed to replace story with glorified technology and explosions, I find Midsomer Murders to be extremely interesting and absorbing, in that you have to follow the whole episode to understand Barnaby's train of thought as he, at the end, discovers who the murderer is, and much like Poirot, explains their crime to them in great detail.