NIGHTWISH SURVIVOR 2015: Results -> Ghost Love Score wins!

[Night Prowler]

It was a close battle though, that helped me decide

 

[Detective Beauregard]

I don't care, Ghost Love Score for the win!

 

[Night Prowler]

Shit, you were supposed to only vote for 1 song, forgot to change the setting But it doesn't matter because Beauty is a goner anyway, it'd lose the tie to Ever Dream by a single vote:

Ever Dream - v:22, r:30, a:0,7333
Beauty Of The Beast - v:23, r:30, a:0,7667

 

[Night Prowler]

Top 10
01.
02.
03. Beauty Of The Beast
04. Shudder Before The Beautiful
05. Nemo
06. She Is My Sin
07. Élan
08. Yours Is An Empty Hope
09. Sahara
10. End Of All Hope

 

[Night Prowler]

Ever Dream.

 

[Brigantium]

GLS.

 

[Night Prowler]

 

[Brigantium]

Ever Dream is the quintessential Nightwish to me.

 

[MrKnickerbocker]

Easiest choice all game.

 

[Detective Beauregard]

This is painfully obvious.

 

[Unknown One]

I nearly voted both, because NP allowed it

 

[JudasMyGuide]

I too voted Ghost Love Score, because while - as Brigs have said - Ever Dream is the quintessential Nightwish song (or close to it; wouldn't be my # 1 anyway), Ghost Love Score is unbelievably astonishing on Showtime, Storytime and cheesy everywhere else.

 

[Brigantium]

I too voted Ghost Love Score, because while - as Brigs have said - Ever Dream is the quintessential Nightwish song (or close to it; wouldn't be my # 1 anyway), Ghost Love Score is unbelievably astonishing on Showtime, Storytime and cheesy everywhere else.

 

[Night Prowler]

Spoiler: Rules

Top 10
01. Ghost Love Score
02. Ever Dream
03. Beauty Of The Beast
04. Shudder Before The Beautiful
05. Nemo
06. She Is My Sin
07. Élan
08. Yours Is An Empty Hope
09. Sahara
10. End Of All Hope

Elvenpath (5+1)
Beauty & The Beast (1)
The Carpenter (1)
Astral Romance (5+1)
Angels Fall First (1)
Tutankhamen (5+1)
Nymphomaniac Fantasia (1)
Know Why The Nightingale Sings (2)
Lappi (Lapland) (5)
A Return To The Sea (2)
Once Upon A Troubadour (1)

Stargazers (7+5)
Gethsemane (7+4)
Devil & The Deep Dark Ocean (2)
Sacrament Of Wilderness (3)
Passion & The Opera (7+2)
Swanheart (1)
Moondance (7)
The Riddler (3)
The Pharaoh Sails To Orion (3)
Walking In The Air (3)
Nightquest (3)
Sleeping Sun (4)

She Is My Sin (6+12)
The Kinslayer (3)
Come Cover Me (5)
Wanderlust (6)
Two For Tragedy (1)
Wishmaster (6+7)
Bare Grace Misery (3)
Crownless (3)
Deep Silent Complete (2)
Dead Boy's Poem (1)
FantasMic (6+5)
Sleepwalker (2)

Over The Hills & Far Away (8)
10th Man Down (8+3)
Away (1)

Bless The Child (23)
End Of All Hope (24)
Dead To The World (7)
Ever Dream (32)
Slaying The Dreamer (2)
Forever Yours (1)
Ocean Soul (6)
Feel For You (2)
The Phantom Of The Opera (14)
Beauty Of The Beast (31)
Lagoon (1)
The Wayfarer (2)

Dark Chest Of Wonders (4)
Wish I Had An Angel (10)
Nemo (10+13)
Planet Hell (10+5)
Creek Mary's Blood (2)
The Siren (3)
Dead Gardens (1)
Romanticide (2)
Ghost Love Score (10+16)
Kuolema Tekee Taiteilijan (1)
Higher Than Hope (3)
Live To Tell The Tale (2)
White Night Fantasy (1)

The Poet & The Pendulum (7+6)
Bye Bye Beautiful (3)
Amaranth (7+6)
Cadence Of Her Last Breath (2)
Master Passion Greed (1)
Eva (2)
Sahara (7+9)
Whoever Brings The Night (1)
For The Heart I Once Had (1)
The Islander (7)
Last Of The Wilds (4)
7 Days To The Wolves (7)
Meadows Of Heaven (1)
Escapist (3)
While Your Lips Are Still Red (1)

Taikatalvi (1)
Storytime (4+5)
Ghost River (4+6)
Slow, Love, Slow (2)
I Want My Tears Back (4)
Scaretale (2)
Arabesque (1)
Turn Loose The Mermaids (1)
Rest Calm (3)
The Crow, The Owl & The Dove (1)
Last Ride Of The Day (4+5)
Song Of Myself (1)
Imaginaerum (2)

Shudder Before The Beautiful (16)
Weak Fantasy (8)
Élan (13)
Yours Is An Empty Hope (12)
Our Decades In The Sun (2)
My Walden (1)
Endless Forms Most Beautiful (9)
Edema Ruh (6)
Alpenglow (2)
The Eyes Of Sharbat Gula (1)
The Greatest Show On Earth (1)
Sagan (1)

 

[Night Prowler]

Thanks to all the voters! This was a fun Survivor, it rekindled my love for Nightwish Satisfied with this one because nothing too blasphemous made it to Top 10, but it could've been better. On to the albums survivor now!

 

[Brigantium]

Cheers for hosting, NP! That's really not a bad top 10 at all, even if I'd prefer a different order and a few different songs in there.

 

[JudasMyGuide]

Nice. Thanks for hosting. The top 10 is definitely not my top 10, but I'm not offended either. It's decent. I still have the top 25 or what was it - that makes a good playlist, if you don't mind missing Alpenglow and a few other treasures

EDIT: My top 10 definitely would include Planet Hell, Alpenglow, Wanderlust and Poet and the Pendulum, if you wanted to know.

 

[Forostar]

Thanks for hosting, Night Prowler!

I find the result a disgrace. Some songs in this top 10 are so forgettable. I can only come to the conclusion that they scored high because they are on the new album (a Floor album). New and good singer (although way less interesting compared to her other work from the past), but the songs don't have that magic. Especially not these.

 

[RTC]

Some of the results are really strange to me. Still think Pharoah Sails To Orion is a top 5 Nightwish song, and it's sad it went out as early as it did.

 

[MrKnickerbocker]

Top 10 needs more Marco.

But cheers for hosting, NP!