Tripped on this topic... Here's my opinion on each song:
Women In Uniform - 8/10 (Hell of a cover.. always loved the spin Maiden gave to it)
I've Got The Fire - Live 9/10 (This is pure gold... pure adrenaline. Even better than the original)
Cross-Eyed Mary - 6.5/10 (Far from my favorite Tull song... Locomotive Breath would give one hell of a cover)
I've Got The Fire - 8/10 (Not as relentless as the previous version but still great in all formas)
King Of Twilight - 8.5/10 (Would prefer it only featured King Of Twilight - that part is superb - and not the initial meddley)
Rainbow's Gold - 8/10 (Another Beckett great cover... when it comes to Beckett Maiden can do no wrong
)
Massacre - 8/10 (Cool Lizzy song and one hell of a cover)
All In Your Mind - 9/10 (This cover simply needed to be featured in No Prayer... the managed to completely "Maidenize" the damn thing. Fantastic!)
Communication Breakdown - 5/10 (Love instrumental and the original but I simply think Bruce's voice doesn't fit this Zepp tune)
I'm A Mover - 5.5/10 (Bluesy... ok but simply filler)
Kill Me Ce Soir - 8,5/10 (Great Golden Earring cover. The original's already got that tense feel to it but Maiden got it to a new level)
Space Station #5 - 5.5/10 (Fun cover but quite meh)
I Can't See My Feelings - 4.5/10 (Awful vocal approach on a Budgie filler)
Doctor Doctor - 7.5/10 (Cool Song and Maiden surely nailed this one. Blaze does a really good job here)
My Generation - 7/10 (Would love to listen this one with Bruce's voice: I think it would be way more fitting. Steve playing Entwistle is always a win)
Hocus Pocus - 6.5/10 (Funny take on Focus' tune with Nicko trolling the vocal part)
Space Truckin' - 8/10 (Maiden playing Purple - and mainly Bruce singing Gillian? Sign me Up any time)
That being said... why not? I wouldn't feature every single one nevertheless. Would go with something like:
- I've Got The Fire - Live
- Women In Uniform
- Cross-Eyed Mary
- King Of Twilight
- Rainbow's Gold
- Massacre
- All In Your Mind
- Kill Me Ce Soir
- Doctor Doctor
- My Generation
- Space Truckin'
- Hocus Pocus
Also would prefer they'd record reinterpretations for them all (something i'm to seeing happening at all) but if they wanted to release it as a compilation I'd buy it.