Home By The Sea. How did it get this far? There are several better Collins-era epics, including the recently departed Tonight Tonight Tonight or Domino. Sorry I missed it but did you go through We Can't Dance? Because this top ten is missing the best song Genesis did since Duke: Fading Lights, the closer on We Can't Dance.
In The Cage. Amazing song but not at the level of the first four. And I want to get some higher-ranked Collins-era stuff if I can.
Behind The Lines. My favorite song on Duke, but I can't vote for Afterglow or Mama. Afterglow is magical: next time you hear it, remember that's a first take. Mama is just too damn cool.