GhostofCain
Ancient Mariner
If I were to listen to either of those two albums from start to finish, I'd probably pick BNW, although I think DOD has higher peaks taken individually (Rainmaker, Montsegur, title track, Paschendale).
DOD probably has more "variegate" ideas but I would take one, maybe two tracks out of it, with the candidates being No More Lies and Gates of Tomorrow.
I'd say the high points on DOD are higher (Paschendale in particular), but BNW is more consistent.
EDIT: The stinkers on DOD (No More Lies in particular) stink more though.
Last edited: