Thoughts on Bruce Dickinson's Vocals...

Albie

Keeping an open eye on the Weeping Angels.
....and it's a positive thought.

Well, OK - this is a last.fm journal, but I really would like to share this with people who are not from the said community. And not only that, today for some reason I have felt a little inspired and written two journals and a long rant about religion. God knows where it has all come from. :huh:

For me, one of the most important aspects of the overall Maiden package is Bruce Dickinson's vocals. Now, before you tell me - Maiden had two other vocalists that made very credible contributions (namely Paul Di'anno and Blaze), I am very well aware of this fact. The DiAnno era is when I first got into Maiden, the Blaze era has produced one stunning ("The X Factor") and one very good album (as well as one of the best ever Maiden tracks - "The Clansman") and both of these vocalists should not be forgotten when we talk of Maiden.

However, Bruce is one of the few vocalists in metal that sings with passion and with a sense of dramatics. Seriously, name one better.

What he has the talent to do is to take each line and sing it as you are meant to sing it. Take, for example, these two lines from "Can I Play With Madness", where he sings:

Give me the strength to hold my head up
Spit back in their face


The first line screams desperation. It says that - although I have been trodden on, I must be strong. The second line, seeks for me to fight back. Take no prisoners, if you will. Immerse yourself, for a while, in the character this songs talks of, say the lines to yourself and feel the emotion of it - for that is what Bruce does. Listen to this song again and pay careful attention to the above lines and feel his passion as he sings them. I have heard many an artist to cover this song, but they all sing these two lines like a quivering schoolboy (sorry, but that is how I feel).

This is but one example of Bruce at his best, but there are others. The man is very theatrical in his performance of any line and of any song. Nicko may mock him for his "luvvie" approach to his presence on stage ("oh, time for a costume change"), but it gives Maiden that little bit that few other bands have - proper theatre. And in reality, that it is what it's all about. Don't be surprised if Bruce appears in the odd movie/play or two over the coming decade.

The guy is a genius and one of the biggest reason I have kept faith with Maiden for 26 years.
 
Albie said:
However, Bruce is one of the few vocalists in metal that sings with passion and with a sense of dramatics. Seriously, name one better
Where to begin?  Rob Halford, that's a good starting point :P

All subjective matters aside, I do take in your point that Brucce adds a dimension to Maiden that few other bands can match.  He can make poor songs sound good and good songs sound great.

My favourite Bruce moments would be the screams on "Run to the Hills" and at the start of "The Number of the Beast" ;)
 
Conor said:
Where to begin?  Rob Halford, that's a good starting point :P
But does old Bob have the same dramaticism in his overall performance? From a personal point of view, I really don't think Halford has the same sort of passion as Bruce does. He is good, I'll give him that, but of all the Priest stuff I've heard, he does not match Bruce's theatrics. I mean, do you ever feel the emotion and live for that song's moment when listening to Maiden with Bruce at the helm? Do you not find yourself almost acting out the lines as you sing them - thanks to Bruce's delivery?

I find Bruce's overall performance on the mic brilliant. Few give more heart to the song.

But that is just my opinion.
 
I have that track, Conor, and I love it. I'll agree he is good - very good. But our differences are of our own opinion.

I'm off to play VoC. :D
 
Albie said:
....and it's a positive thought.

Well, OK - this is a last.fm journal, but I really would like to share this with people who are not from the said community. And not only that, today for some reason I have felt a little inspired and written two journals and a long rant about religion. God knows where it has all come from. :huh:

For me, one of the most important aspects of the overall Maiden package is Bruce Dickinson's vocals. Now, before you tell me - Maiden had two other vocalists that made very credible contributions (namely Paul Di'anno and Blaze), I am very well aware of this fact. The DiAnno era is when I first got into Maiden, the Blaze era has produced one stunning ("The X Factor") and one very good album (as well as one of the best ever Maiden tracks - "The Clansman") and both of these vocalists should not be forgotten when we talk of Maiden.

However, Bruce is one of the few vocalists in metal that sings with passion and with a sense of dramatics. Seriously, name one better.

What he has the talent to do is to take each line and sing it as you are meant to sing it. Take, for example, these two lines from "Can I Play With Madness", where he sings:

Give me the strength to hold my head up
Spit back in their face


The first line screams desperation. It says that - although I have been trodden on, I must be strong. The second line, seeks for me to fight back. Take no prisoners, if you will. Immerse yourself, for a while, in the character this songs talks of, say the lines to yourself and feel the emotion of it - for that is what Bruce does. Listen to this song again and pay careful attention to the above lines and feel his passion as he sings them. I have heard many an artist to cover this song, but they all sing these two lines like a quivering schoolboy (sorry, but that is how I feel).

This is but one example of Bruce at his best, but there are others. The man is very theatrical in his performance of any line and of any song. Nicko may mock him for his "luvvie" approach to his presence on stage ("oh, time for a costume change"), but it gives Maiden that little bit that few other bands have - proper theatre. And in reality, that it is what it's all about. Don't be surprised if Bruce appears in the odd movie/play or two over the coming decade.

The guy is a genius and one of the biggest reason I have kept faith with Maiden for 26 years.
I can not agree more, Albie. And it is visible in every song he sang, and every live performance he made. There are so many examples, I'll name few:
DOTD, "Dance of death"- When he sings the intro wearing the outfit that's entirely right for the song. And the way he sings it while sitting on that chair-especially when he moved his head to the side on the line "But no more", you could just feel the spirit of the song and the lyrics. It reminded me of "Summer nights dream".
"Mercenary", Rock in Rio- On the line "You gotta kill to stay alive" he displays so much energy.
And then there's "Blood brothers". There's that quiet intro, and then there's the part when he sings "There are times when I feel I'm afraid for the world"
,and he sings it in a truly dramatic and serious way. He simply means everything he says.
He is such a multitalented person, and for me, the best singer ever- because he combines incredible vocal abilites with a huge stage presence and charisma.
I appreciate Di'Anno's and Blaze's work, but they're not even close to Bruce Dickinson.
 
To me, Bruce sings even better and more emotionally on his solo albums, especially in ballads such as 'Acoustic Song' or 'Arc of Space' (the list is almost infinite). However, two of my favourite moments would be the chorus in 'Kill Devil Hill' and that part in 'Back from the Edge' ('now and then I wonder where the faces from my childhood has gone, like father like son in your bones it lives on, glowing shadows'). Another great example is 'No way out..continued' where he proves that he can sing stunningly in non-metal style also.

As for Rob Halford, I think he can well keep up with Bruce in ballads like 'Before the Dawn' or 'Angel'.
 
Nice opening post, Albie... A few more thoughts then:

I find it impossible to choose my favourite Bruce moments as there are too many. Not forgetting Shadow's thread about the expressive ability of music, I must say that I'm most fond of Bruce on 'Seventh Son' because that was my first meeting with Maiden and he immediately captivated me.

We have also witnessed Bruce as a person, be it on stage during his ramblings, or in his radio show. He is very emotional and outspoken, and that shows in his singing, I think.

And finally, for me it's the warmth in Bruce's voice that makes him so special. Whatever the theme of the lyrics - resistance, anger, sorrow, thoughtfulness, his warm humanity comes through. He just makes me feel comfortable. :)
 
I have to admit, I have only "Tattooed Millionaire" and "Accident of Birth" from Bruce's solo stuff. So on that, I can't comment as much as I can with his Maiden stuff - but most certainly his cover of "All the Young Dudes" has the emotional vocals I referred to. I really should get into it a bit more.

Serratia said:
We have also witnessed Bruce as a person, be it on stage during his ramblings, or in his radio show. He is very emotional and outspoken, and that shows in his singing, I think.
That is what makes the man, I think - his passion. As Nicko said of Bruce:

When he gets a great idea, he won’t let it go and he gets so animated, but other times he would be so intent on what he was thinking about, he would be in another world.[sup]1[/sup]

He seems to me to be one to take his art and give it his best and his best can be astonishing.

[sup]1[/sup]Text extracted from the official Iron Maiden site.
 
Nice post Albie. On the new record I have heard a lot of those passionate lines.

Bruce Dickinson, Rob Halford and good ol' Ronnie James Dio are the best around when it comes to this quality in my humble opinion.

If I were you I would get ALL of Bruce's solo work !

Soon!
  :)
 
Absolutely agree with you, Albie. Bruce Dickinson has that rare quality, that little extra, that makes a great performer. I mean, there are lots of people who can sing great, and play instruments great, but they just don't have that performing quality. And that quality, I think, makes all the difference. An example from another genre of music: Itzhak Perlman. I went to one of his concerts once, and on one of his encores he messed up pretty bad, but the audience loved him anyway because he's just a great peformer and could almost make us believe he did it on purpose. And thats the thing with performing arts. Live in the moment, go all the way, because otherwise, it isn't real.

A great example of Bruce's performing qualities, in my opinion, is his music video for The Tower:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p43879EgfzM
 
Excellent topic Albie :ok: I find that Bruce brings something different to metal as a genre, he's not your typical vocalist, he's classically trained and I find that is what it is that brings something new to the table. One of my favourite examples of his theatrics is Paschendale, on Death On The Road, the costume that he uses, along with the props, make the song feel very realistic and helps hammer it home I think. Bruce's voice obviously isn't the same as it was in the 80's, but he doesn't try to sing in an imitation of what he used to be, he has changed his singing style, which still remains as enjoyable for me as it ever was.

Conor mentioned Rob Halford as an equal dramatic character, but Bruce's stage presence surpasses Rob's to no end. For example, Rob singing Painkiller live on Rising In The East, he stays hunched over while singing (which may, of course, be due to the singing style) and doesn't appear to be really singing to the audience as Bruce always does. Rob seems to be more a stationnary singer, where as Bruce is running all over the place constantly, and is full of energy anytime that I've seen him, live or on video.
 
Albie said:
However, Bruce is one of the few vocalists in metal that sings with passion and with a sense of dramatics. Seriously, name one better.
Although he's not strictly speaking a metal singer I'd say Robert Plant is the best, ever, rock'n'Roll singer.
Amen. :)
Robert_Plant02.jpg
 
@Forostar: I most certainly will get more into Bruce's solo stuff. I don't know why I shied away from it for so long. And as for the lines sung on the album, if you have the bonus DVD you see a small snippet of him sing "These Colours..." where his animation and power he gives is evident - and it was immortalised on series of 1 and 0's.

@Hunlord and Natalie: That is exactly what I was driving at. I hate to use this phrase, but Bruce is so dramatic onstage it is almost camp. That is the reason I suggested he may well get into acting when Maiden take another break, this will not be too surprising after all. Yes, Halford is a superb vocalists, but I have to agree with Hunlord here about him just hunching himself over the mic. But he does have passion - he is just not as theatrical.

@JackKnife: As the picture started to load from the top down (I watched the picture load before I read your words), for that split second I had one name in mind - David Coverdale. At that moment I thought of his take on Mistreated - no singer can match his passion when he sings that. Then I saw the whole picture. Yes, Plant is a great vocalist (not quite as good as Gillan in my view, but vocally I know of none better) and his solo stuff is brilliant. Fate of Nations is a particular favourite album of mine. But Bruce is, overall, better. :)
 
Albie said:
As the picture started to load from the top down (I watched the picture load before I read your words), for that split second I had one name in mind - David Coverdale.
Exactly the same here! :lol: And I adore his laid back 'off-key' singing too (as in the verse in 'Is This Love').

As for Plant, he is breathtaking but lacks the warmth I was talking about earlier. Especially in the slow emotional songs that I know, he seems somehow distant, as if he was only a non-biased story teller.
 
Albie said:
@JackKnife: As the picture started to load from the top down (I watched the picture load before I read your words), for that split second I had one name in mind - David Coverdale. At that moment I thought of his take on Mistreated - no singer can match his passion when he sings that. Then I saw the whole picture. Yes, Plant is a great vocalist (not quite as good as Gillan in my view, but vocally I know of none better) and his solo stuff is brilliant. Fate of Nations is a particular favourite album of mine. But Bruce is, overall, better. :)
He he. David Coverdale is a very good singer, and I love his work, including the controversial Coverdale/Page album. But...
How could I say? Plant is more than brilliant, he's the absolute rock'n'roll singer. I acknowledge that Fate of Nation is great but what could we say about the last record, Mighty Rearranger? Great? super-top-great?  :D
Well, however, it's a matter of taste but if you're interested by Mister Plant I've some resources I'd be very happy to share. ;)
 
JackKnife said:
but what could we say about the last record, Mighty Rearranger? Great? super-top-great?  :D
Well, however, it's a matter of taste but if you're interested by Mister Plant I've some resources I'd be very happy to share. ;)
I'm not familiar with this record - I personally wouldn't mind having a listen to it, myself - but I don't want to break the forum rules. ;)
 
Albie said:
I'm not familiar with this record - I personally wouldn't mind having a listen to it, myself - but I don't want to break the forum rules. ;)
:lol:
I might contact you one day if I were to forget the forum rules; but it's very very unlikely of course.  :halo:
 
Albie said:
I'm not familiar with this record - I personally wouldn't mind having a listen to it, myself - but I don't want to break the forum rules. ;)

Hey, Albie, you seem to have caught that bout of 'randomly embolden certain letters' syndrome. :lol:
 
Back
Top