SIT or SSOASS ?

SIT or SSOASS

  • Somewhere in Time

    Votes: 17 45.9%
  • Seventh Son of a Seventh Son

    Votes: 16 43.2%
  • Any other Maiden album

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Adrian Smith

    Votes: 4 10.8%

  • Total voters
    37
Caught SIT > Moonchild
Wasted Years = Infinite Dreams
Sea of Madness > Can I Play
Heaven can Wait = The Evi That Man Do
The Lonllines < SSOASS
Strange in a Strange Land > The Prophecy
Deja Vú < The Clairvoyant
Alexander the Grat > Only the Good...

SIT is slightly higher in my opinion.
 
There could be a case made for Deja Vu as a potential filler. But I don't see anything else on that album as filler.

Can I Play With Madness, Prophecy and Only the Good Die Young are easily filler IMO.
 
This one is pretty hard for me. Both only have one or two weaker songs, but SIT flows a bit better. Something about Seventh Son seems disjointed, incomplete maybe. But it has higher highs for me. And the weaker songs are still really good. Both of these albums compete for my 3rd place spot in favorite Maiden albums.
 
Probably my favourite album versus the album that bridges their greats with their goods.
SiT, hands down

Great
Wasted, sea of Madness, Loneliness, Deja Vu
Evil

Excellent
Alexander, Stranger
Infinite

Good
Can I Play With Madness, 7th Son, Prophecy, Clairvoyant, Only the Good

Decent
Heaven can Wait, Caught Somewhere

Not a big fan
Moonchild
 
Somewhere in Time is my favorite album ever.

I'd put 7th Son at best as number 13 in Maiden's history. However the more I think about it, I realize just how little desire I usually have to listen to this album. It's probably my least listened to Maiden album. I'm not sure where I'd definitively place it.
 
Back
Top