SABATON SURVIVOR 2015: Results -> Carolus Rex wins!

[Brigantium]

Ghost

 

[MrKnickerbocker]

Art of War, no doubt.

 

[Night Prowler]

Top 10
01.
02.
03. The Art Of War
04. To Hell & Back
05. Gott Mit Uns
06. Wolfpack
07. Attero Dominatus
08. Uprising
09. The Lion From The North / Lejonet Från Norden
10. Night Witches

 

[Night Prowler]

Major blasphemy that these two beat The Art Of War... voting for Carolus for the n-th time

 

[Perun]

What the hell is supposed to be so great about The Art of War?

Or Ghost Division, for that matter...

 

[LooseCannon]

Art of War is quite a good song. But Carolus is best.

 

[Night Prowler]

Carolus is Top 5-10, but not the best. Doesn't translate as good to a live environment, based on live videos I've seen. Gott Mit Uns destroys it live, for example.

 

[Perun]

I'm not going to hear about which Sabaton songs are best from people who buried Anzio six feet deep.

 

[Night Prowler]

It's high enough at #4

 

[Perun]

It's not high enough if it's below Art of War and Ghost Division.

 

[Ariana]

Art of War is my second favourite Sabaton song, only after Carolus. Ghost Division is overrated.

 

[Night Prowler]

Ghost Division is another song that just slipped into the final because no one hated it enough.

 

[MrKnickerbocker]

This is actually a very tough choice: Ghost Division is a great song that is way better live and Carolus Rex is a great song that is better on the album. That said, Carolus Rex was the song that hooked me into Sabaton, so I'm voting for Ghost Division.

Also, Gott Mit Uns should be #1.

 

[Saapanael]

Ghost Division is an awesome power song. There's nothing particularly wrong with it (maybe a bit repetitive), but it probably shouldn't belong to the top 5.
The Art of War has a cool atmospheric intro (Sun Tzu Says) and features some epic riffs, but on the whole is one of the least deserving of a spot in the top 10, imo.

 

[RTC]

Is Ghost really that good? I thought it was a decent opener when I listened to the album it was on, nothing more.

 

[Saapanael]

I messed up a bit. When I said "intro to The Art of War", I meant the song's intro, not Sun Tzu Says. For some reason, I didn't remember that Sun Tzu is followed by Ghost Division.

 

[SinisterMinisterX]

Ghost Division

 

[Brigantium]

Ghost Division.

Is Ghost really that good? I thought it was a decent opener when I listened to the album it was on, nothing more.

Perfect opener live, but I wouldn't consider it the ultimate in Sabaton's music.

Carolus Rex isn't a particular favourite of mine either, I prefer the faster, brassier stuff, but I like the feel of that whole album. Although I'd personally have Gott Mit Uns top, I'm sad Panzer Division went out so long ago, that is very typical Sabaton to me.

 

[Night Prowler]

Spoiler: Rules

Top 10
01. Carolus Rex ▲1
02. Ghost Division ▲4
03. The Art Of War ▲4
04. To Hell & Back ●new
05. Gott Mit Uns ▼2
06. Wolfpack ▼1
07. Attero Dominatus ▲1
08. Uprising ▲2
09. The Lion From The North / Lejonet Från Norden ◄0
10. Night Witches ●new

Out of the Top 10:
Primo Victoria (#1)
Panzer Battalion (#4)

Primo Victoria (12+2)
Reign Of Terror (3)
Panzer Battalion (12)
Wolfpack (12+8)
Counterstrike (3)
Stalingrad (3)
Into The Fire (3)
Purple Heart (2)
Metal Machine (2)
The March To War (1)
Shotgun (1)
Dead Soldier's Waltz (1)

Attero Dominatus (10+7)
Nuclear Attack (10+1)
Rise Of Evil (10)
In The Name Of God (8)
We Burn (1)
Angels Calling (7)
Back In Control (3)
Light In The Black (9)
Metal Crüe (2)
Nightchild (1)

Hellrider (2)
Thundergods (2)
Metalizer (2)
Shadows (1)
Burn Your Crosses (1)
7734 (3+1)
Endless Nights (2)
Hail To The King (3)
Thunderstorm (2)
Speeder (2)
Masters Of The World (3+1)
Dream Destroyer (1)
Introduction (1)
The Hammer Has Fallen (2)
Guten Nacht (1)
Birds Of War (1)

Sun Tzu Says (1)
Ghost Division (10+12)
The Art Of War (10+11)
40:1 (6)
Unbreakable (4)
The Nature Of Warfare (1)
Cliffs Of Gallipoli (6)
Talvisota (2)
Panzerkampf (2)
Union (Slopes Of St. Benedict) (3)
The Price Of A Mile (10)
Firestorm (2)
A Secret (1)
Glorious Land (1)
Swedish Pagans (3)

Coat Of Arms (9)
Midway (1)
Uprising (13)
Screaming Eagles (2)
The Final Solution (4)
Aces In Exile (2)
Saboteurs (1)
Wehrmacht (1)
White Death (9)
Metal Ripper (1)

Dominium Maris Baltici (1)
The Lion From The North / Lejonet Från Norden (10)
Gott Mit Uns (14)
A Lifetime Of War / En Livstid I Krig (2)
1648 (1)
The Carolean's Prayer / Karolinens Bön (2)
Carolus Rex (17)
Killing Ground / Ett Slag Färgat Rött (5)
Poltava (4)
Long Live The King / Konungens Likfärd (2)
Ruina Imperii (1)
Harley From Hell (1)

Night Witches (7)
No Bullets Fly (6)
Smoking Snakes (2)
Inmate 4859 (2)
To Hell & Back (13)
The Ballad Of Bull (1)
Resist & Bite (5)
Soldier Of 3 Armies (3)
Far From The Fame (6)
Hearts Of Iron (3)
Man Of War (1)

 

[Night Prowler]

I'm never satisfied with the results it seems Carolus Rex isn't the best, last 3 songs shouldn't be in Top 10. Primo and Panzer missing out on Top 10 is a blasphemy.

Thanks to all the voters!