Discussion in 'Music Discussion' started by Mosh, Dec 3, 2012.


Top 5 Rush Albums/Next Band

  1. Rush

  2. Fly By Night

  3. Caress Of Steel

  4. 2112

  5. A Farewell To Kings

  6. Hemispheres

  7. Permanent Waves

  8. Moving Pictures

  9. Signals

  10. Grace Under Pressure

  11. Power Windows

  12. Hold Your Fire

  13. Presto

  14. Roll The Bones

  15. Counterparts

  16. Test For Echo

  17. Vapor Trails

  18. Snakes & Arrows

  19. Clockwork Angels

Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    Welcome to Rush week. In the poll there is all the Rush albums, as per Foro's request. Lets vote on our top 5. After the divider is the list of bands, please vote for one.
  2. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    For my top 5 (in chronological order)
    Permanent Waves
    Moving Pictures
    Grace Under Pressure
    Clockwork Angels

    All these albums could be serious contenders for best album.
  3. Cornfed Hick

    Cornfed Hick Puissant

    As has been discussed elsewhere in this forum, side one of the Moving Pictures LP might be the greatest album side EVER. And side two is no slouch either.

    (For those of you born after 1980 -- prior to the advent of compact discs/mp3's, we old farts actually listened to vinyl records, one side at a time. Barbaric, I know, but we made do as best we could. ;))

    Hemispheres and 2112 had their moments, but the best albums start-to-finish were, in order:

    1. Moving Pictures -- by a mile -- a genuine classic, part of the essential rock canon, everyone should own this
    2. Permanent Waves
    3. A Farewell to Kings
  4. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    I like to listen to vinyl, but haven't gotten a MP yet. But I agree, it's my favorite album side. Not only are the songs great, but they really go together well. It's hard for me to listen to one song without hearing the rest.
  5. 425

    425 Starblind

    Ah, one of these where I'm familiar enough with the band. I'm just starting out in music really (heard some Iron Maiden) right around a year ago and the rest is history. But I do have six Rush albums, with getting more Rush being a high priority. Since I only have six, I'll just rank what I have:

    Permanent Waves
    Moving Pictures
    A Farewell to Kings
    Fly By Night

    Moving Pictures is a flawless album, but I like Permanent Waves just a bit better because of the opening trio of The Spirit of Radio -> Freewill -> Jacob's Ladder.

    There's really nothing new to say about the first, or even really the second, but I do want to say about Jacob's Ladder that I think it generally doesn't get much credit as one of Rush's great songs. A great atmospheric track that I enjoy all the way through, and while the fact that there are few lyrics is, in this case, a good thing, the few vocal parts are really excellent moments in the song. Particularly the latter two; when Geddy's voice comes in it really seems to be another instrument adding to the overall atmosphere, especially "light streams down in bright unbroken beams." The lyrics don't seem to be designed to tell a story or anything of that sort, they just basically say "This is the phenomenon that we are trying to depict in music here. This is what scene you should be imagining. Enjoy." Such a simple concept, but a great, complex, atmospheric song. Natural Science is a great epic that is at least on par with Camera Eye. As far as the rest of Permanent Waves goes, Different Strings is a good Rush ballad, and Entre Nous is an oft-neglected track that is weaker than the two tracks of similar style and length but is still a good song.

    Anyway, I'm definitely making a priority out of getting more Rush. I'm planning on getting Caress of Steel (I have a fascination with albums that are widely regarded as poor by the band's standards but have a few people that love them, like Iron Maiden's The X Factor) and Clockwork Angels soon, and then I'll probably go back to the beginning and get the rest in chronological order.
  6. mckindog

    mckindog Living for Sanctuary from the law Staff Member

    Moving Pictures is the best Rush album and perhaps the best album (album, not just side) of all time.
    Counterparts, Grace Under Pressure, Permanent Waves and Clockwork Angels round out the top five, with the order constantly changing. (Clicked without voting Mosh, if you want to add to the poll.)
    Signals, 2112, Farewell to Kings are also four-star, essential, albums.
    I rank Hemispheres lower than most do because I don't like particularly the title track, and Vapor Trails higher, partly because of the lyrics (among Peart's best).
    The synth years rank lower because of their lack of heaviness, but the songs and the playing are still amazing.
    Caress of Steel and the debut are their worst, but every Rush album has its moments and is worth exploring.
  7. Forostar

    Forostar Ancient Mariner

    Thanks for not forgetting that poll Mosh. I need to give it some thought, hope you don't mind if it would be later than 9 December (not sure if I'll make it; a busy upcoming week).
    Mosh likes this.
  8. The Flash

    The Flash Dennis Wilcock did 9/11

    1. Moving Pictures : A true masterpiece. Level of song quality is enough to battle with every single album around, especially with the first side. Other three songs are also really good and the album flows perfectly.
    2. Hemispheres : This one contains my favorite Rush song (Strangiato), also one that will make my Top 10 with ease (Hemispheres). The Trees is also a wonderful song. A pure progressive rock classic.
    3. A Farewell to Kings : I may not like Book I as Book II but I do like it and I list the title track as one of my favorite Rush songs. And of course there's Xanadu which doesn't really need words to explain its quality.
    4. Permanent Waves : Best overall flow of any of those, probably. Just fun to listen to in its entirety.
    5. Grace Under Pressure : I just love the new-wave feel to it. An amazing blend, features a Top 5 song (Red Sector A) and you can't also pass up on Distant Early Warning, The Enemy Within and Between the Wheels.

    6. 2112
    7. Signals
    8. Counterparts
    9. Clockwork Angels
    10. Vapor Trails
    11. Snakes & Arrows
    12. Power Windows
    13. Roll the Bones
    14. Fly by Night
    15. Test for Echo
    16. Presto
    17. Hold Your Fire
    18. Caress of Steel
    19. Rush
  9. Vap

    Vap Ancient Mariner

    Permanent Waves
    Moving Pictures
    Grace Under Pressure
    Power Windows

    Those five are my favorite (not in order). Circumstances is the only clearly weaker song of Hemispheres, but even it is ok. Permanent Waves is a very solid album from start to finish. Moving Pictures is a perfect album. Grace Under Pressure is an another very solid album. Power Windows has some of Rush's most overlooked songs.
  10. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    That's cool, just because the week is over doesn't mean we can't continue to discuss :)

    I think I'd rank Test For Echo lower than both of those. Hold Your Fire has better moments, but it I'd also put it with those lower albums.

    Strangiato is also my favorite Rush song. I guess the only reason Hemispheres isn't my #1 is the length. It feels shorter than the rest of Rush's catalog.
  11. Forostar

    Forostar Ancient Mariner

    Permanent Waves is about three quarter of a minute shorter (and thus the shortest album). Perhaps it feels longer than Hemispheres because it has more songs.
  12. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    Probably. Hemispheres' long songs go by quickly for me, while Jacob's Ladder and Natural Science both feel quite long, probably because they have a lot of different parts.
  13. Mosh

    Mosh The years just pass like trains Staff Member

    And it looks like a tie between Permanent Waves and Moving Pictures. Not surprised with these results at all.
  14. Forostar

    Forostar Ancient Mariner

    I am probably going to break that tie. I am pretty sure Permanent Waves won't be in it, but on the other hand I am not sure which albums will be in it (I know four of them, but have not decided on the no. 5).

    EDIT: I see mckindog hasn't voted yet either.
  15. Night Prowler

    Night Prowler CriedWhenBazzaSued Staff Member

    Dammit I forgot to vote for an album. I choose Moving Pictures.
  16. mckindog

    mckindog Living for Sanctuary from the law Staff Member

    Moving Pictures is my number one.
  17. Forostar

    Forostar Ancient Mariner

    Mine too.
  18. harrisdevot

    harrisdevot Priest of the Holy Wristband

    Seeing that so many Maiden fans loved Rush, I checked it out, buying Clockwork Angels. That's a really fantastic album : the title track and headlong flight are incredible. The vocals and basslines are awesome. I regret now to have paid them so little attention in the past : for me, Rush was just commercial hard-rock band, and I realize how stupid I was. Looking at your personal charts, I see it is not that high, so I'm looking forward to hearing those you consider the best ones.
  19. mckindog

    mckindog Living for Sanctuary from the law Staff Member

    Clockwork Angels is fantastic — in my top five.
    And they really do share a lot of what makes Maiden awesome.
    But they have been a lot more varied over the years.
  20. Vap

    Vap Ancient Mariner

    Clockwork Angles isn't in my top five but it's close. I've got one pretty controversial choice in my top 5 - Power Windows - because right now I happen to like it a lot. Other times it might be A Farewell To Kings, sometimes even Signals. Clockwork Angels is such a great album it might be a top 5 album for me sometime. As for my favorite album, it's Moving Pictures.

    I've found myself really liking the songs Jacob's Ladder and The Body Electric lately. I think we killed Jacob's Ladder too soon in the survivor.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice