How The West Was Won - Led Zeppelin
Format: CD/Digial
How The West Was Won the live album showing off
Led Zeppelin supporting their 4th album, their legendary fourth untitled release, as well as showing off 3 tracks from their forthcoming
Houses Of The Holy album. The package kicks off with
Immigrant Song, heavy as all hell with
Robert delivering the stellar opening wails effortlessly. The track feels slower than the studio version but I do feel it actually is the same speed this is one of those tracks that always seems faster than it actually is. Such an iconic track, simplistic, rocking and punchy as all hell, a brilliant composition from the bands third album. This rendition is extended with an outro solo section from the band which brings the track to your average modern rocker length seeing as the track didn’t even clock in at 2 and a half minutes in its original setting.
Heartbreaker is second on the bill, a track which I’ve never gotten the massive love for but then again this is
Led Zeppelin they have so many good tracks and
II never stuck to me as well as some of their other albums. The first two minutes of the track stick to the original formula before
Jimmy Page takes an extended guitar solo section which seems a little early on in a show for an unaccompanied solo but well once again this is
Zeppelin the extended solo is a nice way for the guitar god to show off but it doesn’t need to be this long, considering we have
Dazed And Confused coming later on. The band comes back after 3 minutes of soloing to continue on their hard rocking approach and the energy returns to full strength. A strong closing segment right till the end, with
Robert coming in right at the end to finish off the final verse. Stellar performance, with a little too long a solo.
Black Dog comes in with the
Out On The Tiles drum intro, one of the much beloved
Led Zeppelin tracks which I feel are brought truly to life on the live renditions, later versions would feature
Bring It On Home as an introduction and I personally prefer that introduction but seeing as we get the whole version of that track I think this intro works. A roaring rocker which is absolutely nailed live and so much sheer power. Much better than the studio version with a nice extended jam session which is tasteful in both length and delivery. The band now provides the audience a preview of their upcoming
Houses Of The Holy album. Performing
Over The Hills And Far Away the band slows it down a little for the calm introduction much befitting of the bands fifth studio effort, the shift to up-tempo hits hard and is done seamlessly another great rendition of a classic track. The band truly slows it down for the next track, the blues epic
Since I’ve Been Loving You from their third album. One of my all-time favourite
Zeppelin tracks, the track is haunting and beautiful from start to finish, let’s see how this rendition holds up and with that stellar introduction it is shaping up to being quite the good one, the opening verse is sung fairly quick compared to earlier live versions but
Robert sounds amazing.
Bonzo delivers some great drum fills on the track and as always
John Paul Jones does a stellar bass work. This rendition seems less bluesy and more towards the rock side of their sound. The bluesier approach does come in more towards the end of the track and as a whole the track is stellar however it pales in comparison to the bands rendition on their
BBC Sessions live album, which is an example of perfection. Although then again the track is still an absolute masterpiece.
Stairway is up next, a track which I believe
Robert wasn’t sick of yet at this time. A track which needs no explanation, the track has been one of the biggest rock epics no tracks since its inception and release in 1971. This rendition is strong, well delivered. It isn’t as emotionally charged as it could be.
Going to California opens the acoustic section of the show, a tender ballad which shows off the bands softer more emotional side. A beautiful little piece,
Robert’s voice is so incredibly powerful and the stripped approach of the track just allows him to shine throughout. Wow.
That’s The Way follows up continuing on the acoustic format, not a track I’m super familiar with from the bands vast catalog, it clearly is about friendship which due to circumstances cannot be followed through with. The track is pleasant but the band has stronger tracks which could have been done in its spot, such as
The Battle Of Evermore, Gallows Pole; Babe, I’m Gonna Leave You or Thank You. The follow uptrack is the final in the acoustic set
Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp another track from the bands third album. This is the closer for the first CD of the album. The track has a very different feeling from the previous acoustic tracks, it is uptempo and features a very prominent stomp, there is a country esc feel to it. It is a decent rendition; it falls into the list of tracks which could have been replaced with something from above more effectively.
-Drunken review begins here-
Disc 2 begins with
Dazed And Confused the track extended to a massive 25 minutes in length, the introduction is extended a fair bit, I don’t get why the band had to extend it as much as they did, I get some extended solos but to add 19 minutes to a track is a lot more, honestly the tempo of the track is slowed too much and
Roberts vocals seem a little disjointed as a result… not to mention the extra length of fluff doesn’t really amuse me too much. The studio version of this track is amazing, the added improvisations from
Jimmy Page are interesting to an extent however, one or two small additions throughout the track would have been better than the massive additional solo. The additions show off the man’s amazing talent but I just don’t get the whole fuss about adding it all to a singular track, surely small additions throughout many different songs would be better? Being a child of the late 90s, I don’t see why this style was super popular yes it would have been great but honestly they turned an epic song into a piss break. This rendition does include some medley components of two tracks which had yet to be released being
Walters Walk from
Coda and
The Crunge from
Houses Of The Holy. But they don’t come into play till after 15 minutes of
Dazed And Confused bloated runtime. As these additions come in the quality of the track does greatly increase and the band as a whole are playing instead of just being self-indulgence by
Page. What Is And What Should Never Be comes in similar to
Over The Hills And Far Away the two tracks I’ve always considered very similar structurally, both songs are great but I prefer the latter, although I don’t listen to either often, this track is a nice shift as the band sticks to the original formula throughout and the track is shorter and concise. A good vocal performance from
Robert having had nearly half an hour to relax his pipes.
Dancing Days comes up next, once again a brand new track which the crowd hasn’t heard before and sticking to the original. I’d be interested to hear
No Quarter without the massive additions they did for the live show on a package like this. A nice and short track, but probably one of the more filler tracks from the album as a whole, well performed and better than the original but not on par with what happened prior to it.
Disc 3 closes out with
Moby Dick which is roughly 18 minutes too long for my liking, I’m fine with a short instrumental or drum solo, but a 20 minute track of which the majority of it is a drum solo is far from necessary, especially so close to
Dazed And Confused. I do not like drum solos, I don’t get the point behind them when they are five minutes, let alone 20. Yes he is immensely talented but I don’t need any more self-indulgence I’d rather hear 2 more tracks with a small drum solo than this extension to a track I already think wasn’t worth of being on an album in the first place. It goes on far too long.
Disc 3 opens up with a medley rendition of
Whole Lotta Love which is a song which I feel on the studio album could have been about 2 minutes shorter and far more effective, but the usage in a medley fashion works well for the track, live this track is far stronger than the original version, I had the privilege of seeing
Plant play this in 2018 with his solo band. With the original track only taking up a short component of the actual runtime the band adds in little covers which they have chosen into the mix, and later in their career I believe this would shift to being of tracks they couldn’t get into the setlist but wanted to share parts of live. A whole band performance and once again strong vocals from
Plant. I think this is a far better way to extend a track than to just add noodling solos, especially for a live album, but then again this is authentic
Zeppelin, my version has a section of the medley removed due to copyright which creates a slight disconnect, the performance is great throughout but once again the question is raised, why not include another actual
Zeppelin Track in leiu of this extension, why not
Communication Breakdown, Good Times, Bad Times or When The Levee Breaks? It goes on too long, but it is much better as a whole than
Dazed And Confused and Moby Dick. The encore begins with
RockAnd Roll a track which the studio version hasn’t done much for me over the years but I cannot deny it is a nice short rocker that the band hasn’t traditionally extended to excessive lengths. A brief drum introduction leads into the rocker, the track is short and concise, great for crowd energy and a nice all around accessible tune. The final “new” track to be performed would be
The Ocean another reveal from the bands upcoming album, in this case the albums closer. The final track which sticks to its own normal rendition and it does quite well as a whole, the track has been used mostly as an encore for the band throughout their career and while it is a nice track I think they have better tracks suited for this portion of the show, plus the track is a nice short piece which could have been used to give some breath to the normal setlist. Oh well, they sound great throughout and the track fits well.
Bring It On Home/Bring It On Back closes out the show, one of the bands best choices for closers, extended slightly, featuring the full introduction with the harmonica from the first album, that riff is stellar and easily one of the best in the bands immense catalog. A brilliant blazing performance from start to finish, it embodies all aspects of the band perfectly throughout it all.
La Drone/Immigrant Song - 10/10
Heartbreaker - 9/10
Black Dog - 9.5/10
Over The Hills And Far Away - 9.5/10
Since I've Been Loving You - 9.5/10
Stairway To Heaven - 9/10
Going To California - 10/10
Thats The Way - 8/10
Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp - 8/10
Dazed And Confused - 7/10
What Is And What Should Never Be - 9/107
Dancing Days - 8.5/10
Moby Dick - 6/10
Whole Lotta Love - 8/10
Rock And Roll - 9/10
The Ocean - 9/10
Bring It On Home/Bring It On Back - 10/10
Adjusted 83%
Overall 88%
4 Stars
Brilliant performances held back by self indulgence. Album 400 completed!