Pink Floyd 2013 survivor finished: Time is still #1

Forostar · Jan 20, 2013

Vap said:
Foro, I didn't count your vote for Let There Be More Light.

Cheers!

First five + A Saucerful of Secrets

Moon Child · Jan 20, 2013

Astronomy Domine
Arnold Layne
See Emily Play

Vap · Jan 22, 2013

Eliminated: <4|>
Astronomy Domine [8] <|19>
Lucifer Sam [8] <|16>
Flaming [8] <|26>
Green Is The Colour [4] <|7>

Promoted:
Arnold Layne (Quarterfinals)
See Emily Play (Semifinals)
The Nile Song (Quarterfinals)
Cymbaline (Semifinals)

Ummagumma joins the game!

- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.

- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall (Disc 1))
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.

Code:

{}  = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[]  = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
 
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
 1.                                  [] <|>
 2.                                  [] <|>
 3. Lucifer Sam                      [8] <4|16>
 4. Astronomy Domine                 [8] <4|19>
 5. Flaming                          [8] <4|26>
 6. Bike                             [2] <5|10>
 7. The Scarecrow                    [2] <6|12>
 8. Instellar Overdrive              [1] <4|5>
 9. Matilda Mother                   [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24                       [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
10. Pow R. Toc H.                    [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
12. The Gnome                        [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
 
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1.                                           [] <|>
2.                                           [] <|>
3.                                           [] <|>
4.                                           [] <|>
5. Point Me At The Sky                       [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg                            [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw                                   [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues                             [1] <4|6>
 
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
 1.                     [] <|>
 2.                     [] <|>
 3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
 4. Crying Song         [3] <3|4>
 5. Cirrus Minor        [3] <3|6>
 6. Main Theme          [3] <3|8>
 7. More Blues          [2] <5|8>
 8. Dramatic Theme      [1] <3|5>
 9. Party Sequence      [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece     [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver         [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar           [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber       [0] <4|4> (tie) <
 
Ummagumma {10}
 1.                                                                                             [] <|>
 2.                                                                                             [] <|>
 3.                                                                                             [] <|>
 4.                                                                                             [] <|>
 5.                                                                                             [] <|>
 6.                                                                                             [] <|>
 7.                                                                                             [] <|>
 8.                                                                                             [] <|>
 9.                                                                                             [] <|>
10.                                                                                             [] <|>
11.                                                                                             [] <|>
12.                                                                                             [] <|>
13.                                                                                             [] <|>

Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)

Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)

Astronomy Domine eliminated? Damn. Anyway, not a big fan of this album.

Sysyphuses
Several Species...
The Grand Vizier's Garden Parties

Moon Child · Jan 22, 2013

I foresee Ummagumma going quick.

Sysyphus
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party

The Flash · Jan 22, 2013

All Ummagumma songs except for The Narrow Way and Grantchester Meadows.

Vap · Jan 24, 2013

Eliminated: [0]
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit <4|4>
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment <4|4>
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance <4|4>
Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict <4|4>
Sysyphus, Part IV <4|4>
Sysyphus, Part III <5|5>
Sysyphus, Part II <5|5>
Sysyphus, Part I <5|5>

Atom Heart Mother and Meddle join the game!

- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.

- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall (Disc 1))
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.

Code:

{}  = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[]  = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
 
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
 1.                                  [] <|>
 2.                                  [] <|>
 3. Lucifer Sam                      [8] <4|16>
 4. Astronomy Domine                 [8] <4|19>
 5. Flaming                          [8] <4|26>
 6. Bike                             [2] <5|10>
 7. The Scarecrow                    [2] <6|12>
 8. Instellar Overdrive              [1] <4|5>
 9. Matilda Mother                   [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24                       [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
10. Pow R. Toc H.                    [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
12. The Gnome                        [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
 
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1.                                           [] <|>
2.                                           [] <|>
3.                                           [] <|>
4.                                           [] <|>
5. Point Me At The Sky                       [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg                            [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw                                   [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues                             [1] <4|6>
 
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
 1.                     [] <|>
 2.                     [] <|>
 3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
 4. Crying Song         [3] <3|4>
 5. Cirrus Minor        [3] <3|6>
 6. Main Theme          [3] <3|8>
 7. More Blues          [2] <5|8>
 8. Dramatic Theme      [1] <3|5>
 9. Party Sequence      [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece     [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver         [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar           [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber       [0] <4|4> (tie) <
 
Ummagumma {10}
 1.                                                                                             [] <|>
 2.                                                                                             [] <|>
 3.                                                                                             [] <|>
 4.                                                                                             [] <|>
 5.                                                                                             [] <|>
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit                                             [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment                                     [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Sysyphus, Part IV                                                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
11. Sysyphus, Part III                                                                          [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II                                                                           [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I                                                                            [0] <5|5> (tie) <
 
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1.                              [] <|>
2.                              [] <|>
3.                              [] <|>
4.                              [] <|>
5.                              [] <|>
 
Meddle {11}
1.                   [] <|>
2.                   [] <|>
3.                   [] <|>
4.                   [] <|>
5.                   [] <|>
6.                   [] <|>

Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)

Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)

Round 10 (Ummagumma)

Atom Heart Mother and Meddle join together as they have just a few songs. While I usually don't want to eliminate this many songs, the ones with four votes would have been quickly voted out the next round anyway.

This is an excellent group of songs. Two songs here would be in my top ten if I had one.

The Narrow Way, Part I
The Narrow Way, Part II
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
San Tropez (I quite like this one, though)
Seamus

Mosh · Jan 24, 2013

What Vap said minus San Tropez. (Very underrated song)

Moon Child · Jan 24, 2013

Narrow Way Part II
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
San Tropez
Seamus

Forostar · Jan 24, 2013

I really like Summer '68. One of the better Wright songs. For the rest I don't really like Atom Heart Mother, and on Meddle I "only" find Echoes (which is very long of course) and One of These Days strong. Fearless just rises above the meh factor. The rest is quite dull material. The next album is even duller.

Atom Heart Mother
If
Fat Old Sun
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
A Pillow Of Winds
San Tropez
Seamus

The Flash · Jan 24, 2013

The Narrow Way Part I
The Narrow Way Part II
Careful with That Axe, Eugene
If
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
A Pillow of Winds
San Tropez

Cosmiceddie · Jan 24, 2013

Stop voting out 'Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast', will you? It's a top ten song for me. By the way, 'Atom Heart Mother' is my second favourite Pink Floyd album.

Vap · Jan 26, 2013

- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.

- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall (Disc 1))
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.

Code:

{}  = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[]  = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
 
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
 1.                                  [] <|>
 2.                                  [] <|>
 3. Lucifer Sam                      [8] <4|16>
 4. Astronomy Domine                 [8] <4|19>
 5. Flaming                          [8] <4|26>
 6. Bike                             [2] <5|10>
 7. The Scarecrow                    [2] <6|12>
 8. Instellar Overdrive              [1] <4|5>
 9. Matilda Mother                   [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24                       [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
10. Pow R. Toc H.                    [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
12. The Gnome                        [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
 
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1.                                           [] <|>
2.                                           [] <|>
3.                                           [] <|>
4.                                           [] <|>
5. Point Me At The Sky                       [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg                            [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw                                   [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues                             [1] <4|6>
 
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
 1.                     [] <|>
 2.                     [] <|>
 3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
 4. Crying Song         [3] <3|4>
 5. Cirrus Minor        [3] <3|6>
 6. Main Theme          [3] <3|8>
 7. More Blues          [2] <5|8>
 8. Dramatic Theme      [1] <3|5>
 9. Party Sequence      [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece     [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver         [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar           [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber       [0] <4|4> (tie) <
 
Ummagumma {10}
 1.                                                                                             [] <|>
 2.                                                                                             [] <|>
 3.                                                                                             [] <|>
 4. The Narrow Way, Part I                                                                      [1] <4|5>
 5. The Narrow Way, Part II                                                                     [1] <5|6>
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit                                             [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment                                     [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Sysyphus, Part IV                                                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
11. Sysyphus, Part III                                                                          [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II                                                                           [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I                                                                            [0] <5|5> (tie) <
 
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1.                              [] <|>
2.                              [] <|>
3.                              [] <|>
4.                              [] <|>
5. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast [0] <6|6>
 
Meddle {11}
1.                   [] <|>
2.                   [] <|>
3.                   [] <|>
4.                   [] <|>
5. Seamus            [0] <5|5>
6. San Tropez        [0] <6|6>

Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)

Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)

Round 10 (Ummagumma)

Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)

Tough round.

A Saucerful Of Secrets
Grantchester Meadows
If
A Pillow Of Winds

Mosh · Jan 26, 2013

Narrow Way
If
Fat Old Sun

Forostar · Jan 26, 2013

A Saucerful Of Secrets
The Narrow Way, Part III
Atom Heart Mother
If
Fat Old Sun
A Pillow Of Winds
Fearless

The Flash · Jan 26, 2013

A Saucerful of Secrets
The Narrow Way, Part III
Careful with That Axe, Eugene
If
Fat Old Sun
A Pillow of Winds
Fearless

Moon Child · Jan 26, 2013

Damn, this one is hard now.

Grantchester Meadows
Atom Heart Mother

Vap · Jan 28, 2013

Eliminated: <4|6>
A Saucerful Of Secrets [11]
The Narrow Way, Part III [2]
If [1]

Promoted:
Grantchester Meadows (Quarterfinals)
Careful With That Axe, Eugene (Semifinals)

Obscured By Clouds joins the game!

- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.

- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall (Disc 1))
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.

Code:

{}  = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[]  = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
 
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
 1.                                  [] <|>
 2.                                  [] <|>
 3. Lucifer Sam                      [8] <4|16>
 4. Astronomy Domine                 [8] <4|19>
 5. Flaming                          [8] <4|26>
 6. Bike                             [2] <5|10>
 7. The Scarecrow                    [2] <6|12>
 8. Instellar Overdrive              [1] <4|5>
 9. Matilda Mother                   [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24                       [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
10. Pow R. Toc H.                    [0] <4|4>  (tie)   <
12. The Gnome                        [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5>  (tie) <
 
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1.                                           []  <|>
2.                                           []  <|>
3.                                           []  <|>
4. A Saucerful Of Secrets                    [11] <4|6>
5. Point Me At The Sky                       [6]  <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg                            [3]  <6|15>
7. See-Saw                                   [2]  <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues                             [1]  <4|6>
 
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
 1.                     [] <|>
 2.                     [] <|>
 3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
 4. Crying Song         [3] <3|4>
 5. Cirrus Minor        [3] <3|6>
 6. Main Theme          [3] <3|8>
 7. More Blues          [2] <5|8>
 8. Dramatic Theme      [1] <3|5>
 9. Party Sequence      [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece     [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver         [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar           [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber       [0] <4|4> (tie) <
 
Ummagumma {10}
 1.                                                                                             [] <|>
 2.                                                                                             [] <|>
 3. The Narrow Way, Part III                                                                    [2] <4|6>
 4. The Narrow Way, Part I                                                                      [1] <4|5>
 5. The Narrow Way, Part II                                                                     [1] <5|6>
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit                                             [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment                                     [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
 6. Sysyphus, Part IV                                                                           [0] <4|4> (tie)  <
11. Sysyphus, Part III                                                                          [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II                                                                           [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I                                                                            [0] <5|5> (tie) <
 
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1.                              [] <|>
2.                              [] <|>
3.                              [] <|>
4. If                           [1] <4|6>
5. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast [0] <6|6>
 
Meddle {11}
1.                   [] <|>
2.                   [] <|>
3.                   [] <|>
4.                   [] <|>
5. Seamus            [0] <5|5>
6. San Tropez        [0] <6|6>
 
Obscured By Clouds {}
 1.                         [] <|>
 2.                         [] <|>
 3.                         [] <|>
 4.                         [] <|>
 5.                         [] <|>
 6.                         [] <|>
 7.                         [] <|>
 8.                         [] <|>
 9.                         [] <|>
10.                         [] <|>

Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)

Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)

Round 10 (Ummagumma)

Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)

A nice album. Not much else.

I'll vote later.

Forostar · Jan 28, 2013

Atom Heart Mother
Fat Old Sun
A Pillow Of Winds
Fearless
When You're In
Burning Bridges
The Gold It's In The...
Wot's... Uh The Deal?
Mudmen
Childhood's End
Absolutely Curtains

Moon Child · Jan 28, 2013

Woah! Not much love for Obscured I see.

Atom Heart Mother
Free Four
Stay
Absolutely Curtains

Forostar · Jan 28, 2013

Nope. Quite a boring album, mostly.

Pink Floyd 2013 survivor finished: Time is still #1

Satisfied with the results?

Yes

No

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Dennis Wilcock did 9/11

Ancient Mariner

PM me your Opeth album rankings!

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Dennis Wilcock did 9/11

Back From The Edge

Ancient Mariner

PM me your Opeth album rankings!

Ancient Mariner

Dennis Wilcock did 9/11

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner

Ancient Mariner