Pink Floyd 2013 survivor finished: Time is still #1
- Thread starter Vap
- Start date
The Flash
Dennis Wilcock did 9/11
No to all of that except for the last one.
Vap
Ancient Mariner
Pink Floyd survivor 2013 top ten:
1.
2.
3.
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
It's the top 3, max votes limited to just one.
We've got the same top 3 as last time. As much as I love Shine (and Comfortably Numb) I want Time to win too.
Comfortably Numb
1.
2.
3.
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
It's the top 3, max votes limited to just one.
- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.
- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall, Disc 1)
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.
- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall, Disc 1)
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.
Code:
{} = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[] = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
1. See Emily Play [39] <4|10>
2. Arnold Layne [35] <4|15>
3. Lucifer Sam [8] <4|16>
4. Astronomy Domine [8] <4|19>
5. Flaming [8] <4|26>
6. Bike [2] <5|10>
7. The Scarecrow [2] <6|12>
8. Instellar Overdrive [1] <4|5>
9. Matilda Mother [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24 [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Pow R. Toc H. [0] <4|4> (tie) <
12. The Gnome [0] <5|5> (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5> (tie) <
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1. Let There Be More Light [41] <5|7>
2. Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun [38] <5|15>
3. Remember A Day [17] <4|8>
4. A Saucerful Of Secrets [11] <4|6>
5. Point Me At The Sky [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues [1] <4|6>
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
1. Cymbaline [36] <5|6>
2. The Nile Song [32] <4|12>
3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
4. Crying Song [3] <3|4>
5. Cirrus Minor [3] <3|6>
6. Main Theme [3] <3|8>
7. More Blues [2] <5|8>
8. Dramatic Theme [1] <3|5>
9. Party Sequence [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber [0] <4|4> (tie) <
Ummagumma {10}
1. Careful With That Axe, Eugene [30] <4|7>
2. Grantchester Meadows [26] <5|12>
3. The Narrow Way, Part III [2] <4|6>
4. The Narrow Way, Part I [1] <4|5>
5. The Narrow Way, Part II [1] <5|6>
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Sysyphus, Part IV [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part III [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I [0] <5|5> (tie) <
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1. Summer '68 [33] <6|18>
2. Atom Heart Mother [29] <4|27>
3. Fat Old Sun [4] <5|13>
4. If [1] <4|6>
5. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast [0] <6|6>
Meddle {11}
1. Echoes [38] <6|16>
2. One Of These Days [34] <7|25>
3. A Pillow Of Winds [5] <4|17>
4. Fearless [5] <5|15>
5. Seamus [0] <5|5>
6. San Tropez [0] <6|6>
Obscured By Clouds {13}
1. Obscured By Clouds [27] <4|4>
2. Wot's... Uh The Deal? [24] <6|11>
3. Childhood's End [1] <4|5> (tie) <
3. When You're In [1] <4|5> (tie) <
5. Burning Bridges [1] <4|7>
6. The Gold It's In The... [1] <5|6>
7. Mudmen [1] <5|8>
8. Free Four [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Stay [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Absolutely Curtains [0] <5|5>
The Dark Side Of The Moon {15}
1. [] <|>
2. Us And Them [24] <5|19>
3. Any Colour You Like [10] <3|15>
4. Brain Damage [4] <3|12>
5. Money [4] <4|12>
6. Eclipse [3] <4|8>
7. The Great Gig In The Sky [2] <3|7> (tie) <
7. Breathe [2] <3|7> (tie) <
9. On The Run [1] <4|7>
10. Speak To Me [0] <4|4>
Wish You Were Here {18}
1. [] <|>
2. Have A Cigar [25] <6|45>
3. Wish You Were Here [23] <4|21>
4. Welcome To The Machine [19] <4|28>
5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX [1] <4|7>
Animals {18}
1. Dogs [30] <5|14>
2. Sheep [29] <5|8>
3. Pigs (Three Different Ones) [28] <5|30>
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
The Wall, Disc 1 {20}
1. Mother [21] <4|6>
2. Goodbye Blue Sky [17] <4|8>
3. In The Flesh? [3] <3|4>
4. One Of My Turns [3] <4|8>
5. Empty Spaces [2] <3|6> (tie) <
5. The Thin Ice [2] <3|6> (tie) <
7. Don't Leave Me Now [2] <4|6> (tie) <
7. What Shall We Do Now? [2] <4|6> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part III [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Young Lust [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part II [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part I [1] <2|4> (tie) <
13. Goodbye Cruel World [1] <3|5>
14. The Happiest Days Of Our Lives [0] <3|3>
The Wall, Disc 2 {24}
1. [] <|>
2. Hey You [16] <5|14>
3. Run Like Hell [8] <6|16>
4. In The Flesh [2] <7|10>
5. The Trial [2] <7|11>
6. Waiting For The Worms [1] <4|6>
7. Nobody Home [1] <5|7>
8. Vera [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Is There Anybody Out There? [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Outside The Wall [0] <5|5>
11. Stop [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. The Show Must Go On [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. Bring The Boys Back Home [0] <6|6> (tie) <
The Final Cut {27}
1. The Final Cut [13] <4|10>
2. The Post War Dream [9] <6|14>
3. Not Now John [2] <6|9>
4. The Hero's Return [1] <3|5>
5. The Fletcher Memorial Home [1] <4|6>
6. When The Tigers Broke Free [1] <5|7>
7. Two Suns In The Sunset [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. The Gunner's Dream [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. One Of The Few [0] <3|3> (tie) <
10. Southampton Dock [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Paranoid Eyes [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Your Possible Pasts [0] <4|4> (tie) <
A Momentary Lapse Of Reason {30}
1. Sorrow [12] <5|10>
2. One Slip [9] <5|20>
3. Yet Another Movie [2] <5|8>
4. On The Turning Away [1] <4|6> (tie) <
4. Learning To Fly [1] <4|6> (tie) <
6. Terminal Frost [1] <5|8>
7. A New Machine, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. A New Machine, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. The Dogs Of War [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. Signs Of Life [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Round And Around [0] <5|5>
The Division Bell {33}
1. High Hopes [9] <7|16>
2. Keep Talking [5] <5|16>
3. What Do You Want From Me [5] <6|15>
4. Wearing The Inside Out [2] <6|11>
5. Marooned [1] <5|6>
6. Take It Back [1] <6|7>
7. Poles Apart [1] <7|9>
8. Lost For Words [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Coming Back To Life [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Cluster One [0] <3|3> (tie) <
11. A Great Day For Freedom [0] <4|4>Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
We've got the same top 3 as last time. As much as I love Shine (and Comfortably Numb) I want Time to win too.
Comfortably Numb
Moon Child
Ancient Mariner
Shine On
Vap
Ancient Mariner
Pink Floyd survivor 2013 top ten:
1.
2.
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
Shine and Numb tied in the poll, but Shine lost by about .1 at a vote/round comparison.
I love the solo on Comfortably Numb, but Time is a masterpiece in every aspect from start to finish. My vote goes for Comfortably Numb.
1.
2.
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
Shine and Numb tied in the poll, but Shine lost by about .1 at a vote/round comparison.
- Vote for your least favorite songs in the poll.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.
- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall, Disc 1)
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.
- When ten or less songs are left in the poll, the next album joins the game.
- Last two surviving songs from an album are promoted. The song that has had a higher vote count goes to Quarterfinals and the other to Semifinals.
- Last ten songs that survive until the end of album rounds are promoted to the finals.
- You may vote for as many songs as you want to until the top ten.
- In the top ten, you may only vote for three songs max. At top five only up to two. At top three, you may vote for only one song.
- I'll eliminate as many songs as I deem necessary to keep the game fair and running quickly.
- Rounds will be two days long.
- I am including following non-album songs in this survivor:
-- See Emily Play_______________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Arnold Layne________________(The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn)
-- Point Me At The Sky___________(A Saucerful Of Secrets)
-- Careful With That Axe, Eugene____(Ummagumma)
-- What Shall We Do Now?________(The Wall, Disc 1)
-- When The Tigers Broke Free______(The Final Cut)
- The promotion rules apply for the non-album songs as well.
Code:
{} = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[] = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
1. See Emily Play [39] <4|10>
2. Arnold Layne [35] <4|15>
3. Lucifer Sam [8] <4|16>
4. Astronomy Domine [8] <4|19>
5. Flaming [8] <4|26>
6. Bike [2] <5|10>
7. The Scarecrow [2] <6|12>
8. Instellar Overdrive [1] <4|5>
9. Matilda Mother [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24 [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Pow R. Toc H. [0] <4|4> (tie) <
12. The Gnome [0] <5|5> (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5> (tie) <
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1. Let There Be More Light [41] <5|7>
2. Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun [38] <5|15>
3. Remember A Day [17] <4|8>
4. A Saucerful Of Secrets [11] <4|6>
5. Point Me At The Sky [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues [1] <4|6>
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
1. Cymbaline [36] <5|6>
2. The Nile Song [32] <4|12>
3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
4. Crying Song [3] <3|4>
5. Cirrus Minor [3] <3|6>
6. Main Theme [3] <3|8>
7. More Blues [2] <5|8>
8. Dramatic Theme [1] <3|5>
9. Party Sequence [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber [0] <4|4> (tie) <
Ummagumma {10}
1. Careful With That Axe, Eugene [30] <4|7>
2. Grantchester Meadows [26] <5|12>
3. The Narrow Way, Part III [2] <4|6>
4. The Narrow Way, Part I [1] <4|5>
5. The Narrow Way, Part II [1] <5|6>
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Sysyphus, Part IV [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part III [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I [0] <5|5> (tie) <
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1. Summer '68 [33] <6|18>
2. Atom Heart Mother [29] <4|27>
3. Fat Old Sun [4] <5|13>
4. If [1] <4|6>
5. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast [0] <6|6>
Meddle {11}
1. Echoes [38] <6|16>
2. One Of These Days [34] <7|25>
3. A Pillow Of Winds [5] <4|17>
4. Fearless [5] <5|15>
5. Seamus [0] <5|5>
6. San Tropez [0] <6|6>
Obscured By Clouds {13}
1. Obscured By Clouds [27] <4|4>
2. Wot's... Uh The Deal? [24] <6|11>
3. Childhood's End [1] <4|5> (tie) <
3. When You're In [1] <4|5> (tie) <
5. Burning Bridges [1] <4|7>
6. The Gold It's In The... [1] <5|6>
7. Mudmen [1] <5|8>
8. Free Four [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Stay [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Absolutely Curtains [0] <5|5>
The Dark Side Of The Moon {15}
1. [] <|>
2. Us And Them [24] <5|19>
3. Any Colour You Like [10] <3|15>
4. Brain Damage [4] <3|12>
5. Money [4] <4|12>
6. Eclipse [3] <4|8>
7. The Great Gig In The Sky [2] <3|7> (tie) <
7. Breathe [2] <3|7> (tie) <
9. On The Run [1] <4|7>
10. Speak To Me [0] <4|4>
Wish You Were Here {18}
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V [32] <4|30>
2. Have A Cigar [25] <6|45>
3. Wish You Were Here [23] <4|21>
4. Welcome To The Machine [19] <4|28>
5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX [1] <4|7>
Animals {18}
1. Dogs [30] <5|14>
2. Sheep [29] <5|8>
3. Pigs (Three Different Ones) [28] <5|30>
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
The Wall, Disc 1 {20}
1. Mother [21] <4|6>
2. Goodbye Blue Sky [17] <4|8>
3. In The Flesh? [3] <3|4>
4. One Of My Turns [3] <4|8>
5. Empty Spaces [2] <3|6> (tie) <
5. The Thin Ice [2] <3|6> (tie) <
7. Don't Leave Me Now [2] <4|6> (tie) <
7. What Shall We Do Now? [2] <4|6> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part III [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Young Lust [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part II [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part I [1] <2|4> (tie) <
13. Goodbye Cruel World [1] <3|5>
14. The Happiest Days Of Our Lives [0] <3|3>
The Wall, Disc 2 {24}
1. [] <|>
2. Hey You [16] <5|14>
3. Run Like Hell [8] <6|16>
4. In The Flesh [2] <7|10>
5. The Trial [2] <7|11>
6. Waiting For The Worms [1] <4|6>
7. Nobody Home [1] <5|7>
8. Vera [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Is There Anybody Out There? [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Outside The Wall [0] <5|5>
11. Stop [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. The Show Must Go On [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. Bring The Boys Back Home [0] <6|6> (tie) <
The Final Cut {27}
1. The Final Cut [13] <4|10>
2. The Post War Dream [9] <6|14>
3. Not Now John [2] <6|9>
4. The Hero's Return [1] <3|5>
5. The Fletcher Memorial Home [1] <4|6>
6. When The Tigers Broke Free [1] <5|7>
7. Two Suns In The Sunset [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. The Gunner's Dream [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. One Of The Few [0] <3|3> (tie) <
10. Southampton Dock [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Paranoid Eyes [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Your Possible Pasts [0] <4|4> (tie) <
A Momentary Lapse Of Reason {30}
1. Sorrow [12] <5|10>
2. One Slip [9] <5|20>
3. Yet Another Movie [2] <5|8>
4. On The Turning Away [1] <4|6> (tie) <
4. Learning To Fly [1] <4|6> (tie) <
6. Terminal Frost [1] <5|8>
7. A New Machine, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. A New Machine, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. The Dogs Of War [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. Signs Of Life [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Round And Around [0] <5|5>
The Division Bell {33}
1. High Hopes [9] <7|16>
2. Keep Talking [5] <5|16>
3. What Do You Want From Me [5] <6|15>
4. Wearing The Inside Out [2] <6|11>
5. Marooned [1] <5|6>
6. Take It Back [1] <6|7>
7. Poles Apart [1] <7|9>
8. Lost For Words [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Coming Back To Life [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Cluster One [0] <3|3> (tie) <
11. A Great Day For Freedom [0] <4|4>Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
Round 50 (Top 10, #3)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
Round 50 (Top 10, #3)
I love the solo on Comfortably Numb, but Time is a masterpiece in every aspect from start to finish. My vote goes for Comfortably Numb.
Time
Moon Child
Ancient Mariner
Comfortably Numb
Vap
Ancient Mariner
Pink Floyd survivor 2013 winner:
Time
1. Time
no change
2. Comfortably Numb
up 1
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
down 1
4. Echoes
up 2
5. Dogs
up 2
6. Sheep
down 1
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
new!
8. One Of These Days
new!
9. Summer '68
new!
10. Have A Cigar
new!
Out of the top ten:
Wish You Were Here (#4 in 2010/11)
Another Brick In The Wall, Part II (#8 in 2010/11)
High Hopes (#9 in 2010/11)
Hey You (#10 in 2010/11)
Time and Comfortably Numb tied, but Time won by about .1 in a votes/rounds comparison. So, Time is the winner once again!
Pink Floyd:
1. Time
2. Comfortably Numb
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
1. Time
2. Comfortably Numb
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Echoes
5. Dogs
6. Sheep
7. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
8. One Of These Days
9. Summer '68
10. Have A Cigar
Code:
{} = Number of the round that the album joined the game in
[] = Number of rounds the song survived
<|> = Votes the song got when eliminated / all votes the song has gotten
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn {1}
1. See Emily Play [39] <4|10>
2. Arnold Layne [35] <4|15>
3. Lucifer Sam [8] <4|16>
4. Astronomy Domine [8] <4|19>
5. Flaming [8] <4|26>
6. Bike [2] <5|10>
7. The Scarecrow [2] <6|12>
8. Instellar Overdrive [1] <4|5>
9. Matilda Mother [1] <4|7>
10. Chapter 24 [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Pow R. Toc H. [0] <4|4> (tie) <
12. The Gnome [0] <5|5> (tie) <
12. Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk [0] <5|5> (tie) <
A Saucerful Of Secrets {1}
1. Let There Be More Light [41] <5|7>
2. Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun [38] <5|15>
3. Remember A Day [17] <4|8>
4. A Saucerful Of Secrets [11] <4|6>
5. Point Me At The Sky [6] <3|13>
6. Corporal Clegg [3] <6|15>
7. See-Saw [2] <6|9>
8. Jugband Blues [1] <4|6>
Soundtrack From The Film More {5}
1. Cymbaline [36] <5|6>
2. The Nile Song [32] <4|12>
3. Green Is The Colour [4] <4|7>
4. Crying Song [3] <3|4>
5. Cirrus Minor [3] <3|6>
6. Main Theme [3] <3|8>
7. More Blues [2] <5|8>
8. Dramatic Theme [1] <3|5>
9. Party Sequence [1] <4|7>
10. A Spanish Piece [1] <5|8>
11. Quicksilver [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Ibiza Bar [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Up The Khyber [0] <4|4> (tie) <
Ummagumma {10}
1. Careful With That Axe, Eugene [30] <4|7>
2. Grantchester Meadows [26] <5|12>
3. The Narrow Way, Part III [2] <4|6>
4. The Narrow Way, Part I [1] <4|5>
5. The Narrow Way, Part II [1] <5|6>
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part III: Exit [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part II: Entertainment [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. The Grand Vizier's Garden Party, Part I: Entrance [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict [0] <4|4> (tie) <
6. Sysyphus, Part IV [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part III [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part II [0] <5|5> (tie) <
11. Sysyphus, Part I [0] <5|5> (tie) <
Atom Heart Mother {11}
1. Summer '68 [33] <6|18>
2. Atom Heart Mother [29] <4|27>
3. Fat Old Sun [4] <5|13>
4. If [1] <4|6>
5. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast [0] <6|6>
Meddle {11}
1. Echoes [38] <6|16>
2. One Of These Days [34] <7|25>
3. A Pillow Of Winds [5] <4|17>
4. Fearless [5] <5|15>
5. Seamus [0] <5|5>
6. San Tropez [0] <6|6>
Obscured By Clouds {13}
1. Obscured By Clouds [27] <4|4>
2. Wot's... Uh The Deal? [24] <6|11>
3. Childhood's End [1] <4|5> (tie) <
3. When You're In [1] <4|5> (tie) <
5. Burning Bridges [1] <4|7>
6. The Gold It's In The... [1] <5|6>
7. Mudmen [1] <5|8>
8. Free Four [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Stay [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Absolutely Curtains [0] <5|5>
The Dark Side Of The Moon {15}
1. Time [36] <-|17>
2. Us And Them [24] <5|19>
3. Any Colour You Like [10] <3|15>
4. Brain Damage [4] <3|12>
5. Money [4] <4|12>
6. Eclipse [3] <4|8>
7. The Great Gig In The Sky [2] <3|7> (tie) <
7. Breathe [2] <3|7> (tie) <
9. On The Run [1] <4|7>
10. Speak To Me [0] <4|4>
Wish You Were Here {18}
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V [32] <4|30>
2. Have A Cigar [25] <6|45>
3. Wish You Were Here [23] <4|21>
4. Welcome To The Machine [19] <4|28>
5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX [1] <4|7>
Animals {18}
1. Dogs [30] <5|14>
2. Sheep [29] <5|8>
3. Pigs (Three Different Ones) [28] <5|30>
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
4. Pigs On The Wing, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
The Wall, Disc 1 {20}
1. Mother [21] <4|6>
2. Goodbye Blue Sky [17] <4|8>
3. In The Flesh? [3] <3|4>
4. One Of My Turns [3] <4|8>
5. Empty Spaces [2] <3|6> (tie) <
5. The Thin Ice [2] <3|6> (tie) <
7. Don't Leave Me Now [2] <4|6> (tie) <
7. What Shall We Do Now? [2] <4|6> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part III [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Young Lust [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part II [1] <2|4> (tie) <
9. Another Brick In The Wall, Part I [1] <2|4> (tie) <
13. Goodbye Cruel World [1] <3|5>
14. The Happiest Days Of Our Lives [0] <3|3>
The Wall, Disc 2 {24}
1. Comfortably Numb [27] <5|20>
2. Hey You [16] <5|14>
3. Run Like Hell [8] <6|16>
4. In The Flesh [2] <7|10>
5. The Trial [2] <7|11>
6. Waiting For The Worms [1] <4|6>
7. Nobody Home [1] <5|7>
8. Vera [0] <4|4> (tie) <
8. Is There Anybody Out There? [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Outside The Wall [0] <5|5>
11. Stop [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. The Show Must Go On [0] <6|6> (tie) <
11. Bring The Boys Back Home [0] <6|6> (tie) <
The Final Cut {27}
1. The Final Cut [13] <4|10>
2. The Post War Dream [9] <6|14>
3. Not Now John [2] <6|9>
4. The Hero's Return [1] <3|5>
5. The Fletcher Memorial Home [1] <4|6>
6. When The Tigers Broke Free [1] <5|7>
7. Two Suns In The Sunset [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. The Gunner's Dream [0] <3|3> (tie) <
7. One Of The Few [0] <3|3> (tie) <
10. Southampton Dock [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Paranoid Eyes [0] <4|4> (tie) <
10. Your Possible Pasts [0] <4|4> (tie) <
A Momentary Lapse Of Reason {30}
1. Sorrow [12] <5|10>
2. One Slip [9] <5|20>
3. Yet Another Movie [2] <5|8>
4. On The Turning Away [1] <4|6> (tie) <
4. Learning To Fly [1] <4|6> (tie) <
6. Terminal Frost [1] <5|8>
7. A New Machine, Part II [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. A New Machine, Part I [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. The Dogs Of War [0] <4|4> (tie) <
7. Signs Of Life [0] <4|4> (tie) <
11. Round And Around [0] <5|5>
The Division Bell {33}
1. High Hopes [9] <7|16>
2. Keep Talking [5] <5|16>
3. What Do You Want From Me [5] <6|15>
4. Wearing The Inside Out [2] <6|11>
5. Marooned [1] <5|6>
6. Take It Back [1] <6|7>
7. Poles Apart [1] <7|9>
8. Lost For Words [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Coming Back To Life [0] <3|3> (tie) <
8. Cluster One [0] <3|3> (tie) <
11. A Great Day For Freedom [0] <4|4>Round 1 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
Round 50 (Top 10, #3)
Round 51 (Final battle: Time vs. Comfortably Numb)
Round 2 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 3 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 4 (The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Round 5 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 6 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 7 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 8 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 9 (Soundtrack From The Film More)
Round 10 (Ummagumma)
Round 11 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 12 (Atom Heart Mother, Meddle)
Round 13 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 14 (Obscured By Clouds)
Round 15 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 16 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 17 (The Dark Side Of The Moon)
Round 18 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 19 (Wish You Were Here, Animals)
Round 20 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 21 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 22 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 23 (The Wall, Disc 1)
Round 24 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 25 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 26 (The Wall, Disc 2)
Round 27 (The Final Cut)
Round 28 (The Final Cut)
Round 29 (The Final Cut)
Round 30 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 31 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 32 (A Momentary Lapse Of Reason)
Round 33 (The Division Bell)
Round 34 (The Division Bell)
Round 35 (The Division Bell)
Round 36 (Quarterfinals)
Round 37 (Quarterfinals)
Round 38 (Quarterfinals)
Round 39 (Quarterfinals)
Round 40 (Semifinals)
Round 41 (Semifinals)
Round 42 (Semifinals)
Round 43 (Top 10, #10)
Round 44 (Top 10, #9)
Round 45 (Top 10, #8)
Round 46 (Top 10, #7)
Round 47 (Top 10, #6)
Round 48 (Top 10, #5)
Round 49 (Top 10, #4)
Round 50 (Top 10, #3)
Round 51 (Final battle: Time vs. Comfortably Numb)
I would have swapped Have A Cigar and One Of These Days with Let There Be More Light and Atom Heart Mother. But this is still a really great top ten, its got the Animals songs, no undeserving tracks like in 2011 (Hey You, Another Brick 2, huh?) and one particular track I didn't expecet to make it this far at all (Summer '68). There are some nitpicks I have for the order but they don't really matter. I discovered some tracks, particularly from the Gilmour era that I didn't really remember much before while playing.
This was a really fun game, thanks for playing everyone who did!
Very pleased to see the Animals songs in there, and Echoes. I love that one - I visited Pompeii not long after I saw Live at Pompeii for the first time, and it was running through my head all day 
Moon Child
Ancient Mariner
I'm good with Time being number one but if it was number one before, I would have liked to see something else up there. I'm also happy with the top 10 as a whole considering it does have the Animals tracks in there and Echoes. One of These Days is also great. Really the only drum solo type track I can listen too all the way through and not get bored.
I had alot of fun playing this with you guys. It was interesting to see what people liked and didn't like and for me, I liked going back and listening to tracks I hadn't in so long. Now that this is done, I only have one Survivor to keep track of now which is the Adrian one.
I had alot of fun playing this with you guys.
It was interesting to see what people liked and didn't like and for me, I liked going back and listening to tracks I hadn't in so long. Now that this is done, I only have one Survivor to keep track of now which is the Adrian one.
