JudasMyGuide
Ancient Mariner
I mean, yeah, it's not about metal and to me not even about the dynamics, or at least not primarily. A Fair Judgement is all clean vocals and it isn't even particularly hard (or maybe it feels that way, because it's on Deliverance, but still). If Mikael took that one as a blueprint, I think 70 % of Newpeth bashers would be more or less happy.
Still, I don't get the fandom's obsession with Pale Communion (Eternal Rains sounds like an epic introduction that suddenly stops, Eternity is one of the most easily overplayable songs by them ever - and I really hate Mikael's vocals there - Goblin is a throwaway, River sounds way too un-Opethian, etc), but in general, I like Newpeth. BUT I miss what made them special.
There's only ONE song I can't stand - Will O the Wisp. As a song it's okay, nice even, but the way Mikael is aping Ian Anderson (including the vocal inflections - the nasal "You're stuck to the failures of-your-li-hi-hife") makes it sound almost like a parody to me, I can't help but find it strangely grating.
I got a lot of downvotes on Reddit for this opinion, but come on, mates.
Still, I don't get the fandom's obsession with Pale Communion (Eternal Rains sounds like an epic introduction that suddenly stops, Eternity is one of the most easily overplayable songs by them ever - and I really hate Mikael's vocals there - Goblin is a throwaway, River sounds way too un-Opethian, etc), but in general, I like Newpeth. BUT I miss what made them special.
There's only ONE song I can't stand - Will O the Wisp. As a song it's okay, nice even, but the way Mikael is aping Ian Anderson (including the vocal inflections - the nasal "You're stuck to the failures of-your-li-hi-hife") makes it sound almost like a parody to me, I can't help but find it strangely grating.
I got a lot of downvotes on Reddit for this opinion, but come on, mates.