I listened to those two Ayreon albums, and I’m not especially impressed or enamored by them. They’re definitely listenable, but they fall more into the “not really my cup of tea” category.
Personally, I need a bit less “progressive” and a bit more traditional heavy metal. I like the ambient passages, but I also need something to counterbalance them.
I prefer the first two Avantasia albums to this. And definitely
Prequelle and
Skeletá by Ghost.
Now I’m listening to
The Human Equation by Ayreon, and I’m getting much the same feeling - perfectly listenable, but nothing too earth-shattering.
Then “Day Seven: Hope” kicks in. Not heavy, but maybe a little bit in the spirit of The Doors. That one spoke to me immediately. It touched something in my inner psyche right from the start. I like it very much - a little gem indeed.
Hmm… maybe it even wanders a little into Ghost territory.
I think I can pin down why this song affected me: I need drama in a song. I feel like the voices and characters in it are trying to convey something important to me.
There’s a real sense of theatricality here. That’s probably why it connected with me. As I said, I can hear a bit of Ghost in it, and also something of the first Avantasia album.