SilentLucidity said:
Three against one though? Come on...
Who said we were
against you? Not at all! In fact, you turned the 'conversation' to a very interesting topic (have a praise for that!).
I agree with you when you say that total governement control is pure rubbish (although you used other words!). A governement is supposed to be there for the
good of the citizens, well in theory anyway. Absolute control in everything can satisfy some, but will frustrate a large quantity of others. Whereas a minimum of control is necessary -- in crime prevention, for instance (although it depends also on which 'crime' we're talking about, as there is a major difference between peacefully enjoying a spliff on a riverside and murdering a whole family to burgle their house in order to satisfy a heroin habit!) -- a lot of freedom should be granted -- within resonable limits too, of course!
On the other hand, there will always be a chunk of the population that will act like sheep, relying on their governement for almost everything and turning against it as soon as something doesn't quite go the way they want. I'm thinking here of France, where many people take to the street as soon as the tiniest problem occurs (this country is, to my knowledge, the only one where even the unemployed went on strike!), but it isn't the only nation where people think or act in a similar way.
Whether a utopia (or a dystopia as the case may be) is good or bad is a question of individual point of view, it seems. In
1984, the Proles are quite satisfied with their condition and don't want to change it, even if the situation horrifies Winston Smith and -- of course! -- the reader. Huxley's
Brave New World is absolutely perfect for people like Lenina, although it causes a violent response from John the Savage, who completely rebels against it. Our current world is somehow a kind of hybrid of Orwell and Huxley's imaginary societies and some people are quite happy with it. However, and it's an inherent trait of human nature, we are all different and respond in various ways at the individual level, and many of us aren't satisfied at all.
How about dinner, then?