The last 3 Portnoy albums - all of which are inferior to any other album left as a whole. We're judging as a whole. I simply cannot fathom how people can find any of these albums as a whole better than I&W, Awake, FII, or DT.
Black Clouds gets more hate than is deserved. It has 2 amazing songs (Tuscany and Times), 2 good songs (Fortress and Nightmare), and 2 mediocre songs (Rite and Wither). The amount of good-great material is enough to make it a pretty good album overall.
All that said, I still may end up having to vote for it next round..