Forostar said:Do I understand that you mean that if you have seen an older film recently, this topic can't be used? Why would that be less rigid?
General discussion about older films: do you mean, we could talk about old actors and stuff? For the rest I guess most discussions spring from having seen a film recently.
Without distinghing the periods it's hard to estimate this topic on its value I'm afraid, or at least it will be forgotten soon again.
You misunderstand me. If you want to post about an older film you've seen, you can do it in either thread as far as I'm concerned - but I'm not going to move posts back and forth between the two.
Creating a specific division like the one you suggested means you end up with two threads with exactly the same purpose (reviewing films), separated only by time period. If that's the case, I don't see why you need two different threads in the first place. As such, I don't think anything has to be done about the current situation. People can post about anything related to cinema in now watching, and those with a special interest in classic stuff can discuss that here.