Iron Maiden Survivor 2013: Results Thread - Hallowed reclaims the throne!

Satisfied with the results?

  • Total voters
    18
The Rock in Rio version of Sign of the Cross is outstanding; I consider it to be one of the band's best live moments. The Blaze version? Yeah, not so much. Still, there's a few other songs from the X albums that I wish they'd play live more often.
 
I think the studio version of 'Sign of the Cross' is fantastic in its own right. The 'Rock in Rio' version is fantastic of course, but the original recording deserves recognition as one of the best Iron Maiden songs.
 
I like the studio version, but it's lacking a lot of the energy that the live version has. I think most X Factor songs are better live.
 
Besides the lack of energy, I think it's pretty obvious that the vocal melodies were written with Bruce in mind. It's the only song on the album that I think Bruce does/would do a better job.
 
Don't get me wrong, I love Sign of the Cross - top 10 song for me. But killing off Paschendale at 10 remains criminal.

Phantom
Infinite Dreams
Seventh Son

Can we please, please, please put a 9mm in the back of Infinite Dreams's head now?
 
One of these songs is not like the others.
I'm looking at you Infinite Dreams.
Sign of the Cross is so much better.
 
We won't do another tiebreaker, Infinite Dreams gets eliminated.
 
This is a new round, so a new situation, independent of previous tiebreaks.
Depending on the rules: If it calls for a tiebreak then it does. If it doesn't then it doesn't.
 
Regardless of the eventual order, I think this is strong top 10. There are a couple of swaps I'd make, but there's nothing left that I find completely undeserving of consideration.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top