POLL: Best Queen Live Album

What is Queen's best live album?

  • Live Killers

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • Live Magic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Queen on Fire- Live at the Bowl

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Live at Wembley '86

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • Return of the Champions

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Queen Rock Montreal

    Votes: 1 33.3%

  • Total voters
    3

Cornfed Hick

Ancient Mariner
The release of the Live After Death DVD got me thinking about other live recordings of great live bands.  Queen is regarded by many as the greatest live band ever.  And, like Iron Maiden, Queen has released a handful of official live recordings, most recently the October 2007 release of Queen Rock Montreal.  Yet, does Queen have a clear, definitive best live recording, akin to Live After Death?  Weigh in here. 
 
Good question. To be honest, I haven't heard Live At The Bowl, but I heard a good number of bootlegs from that tour, and they were really "on fire" back then. So if the album is anything like those boots, that would be a definite vote for me.
Live Killers is a definite winner. Most people criticise that it is really just a bunch of songs thrown together from so many concerts that even the producers have forgotten which ones, and that it was heavily edited. But I think the album carries a lot of the spirit of Queen, and even though it was edited and overdubbed, it does not try to hide anything. Great album, great performances, and I guess it's "that one" album you need from Queen.
Live At Wembley is another one worth listening to/watching, and worth having. In fact, it's the one that got me into Queen in the first place. It is, in every way, huge. A great performance, very over-the-top, and always mindblowing, but for some odd reason, it's not my favourite. Maybe I just heard one Magic Tour bootleg too many...
...which leads me to Live Magic, which is just some tracks from said tour tossed together for good measure, and not really representative. Back in the day, it was advertised as a "souvenir" for the fans who saw them live back then, and that's pretty much what it is.
Return Of The Champions is much better than I expected, but I think it doesn't live up to the "original" live albums. It has a lot of "Queen" moments on it (such as the performance of Hammer To Fall), but somehow the final spark is missing.

So, my vote goes for Live Killers. It really has the greatest possible amount of Queen crammed into two disks, and for some reason, it always puts me right there when I listen to it. It's edgy, weird, scary, funny and involving.  :ok:
 
As you are the forum's resident Queen expert/enthusiast, I'm glad you responded, Perun.  I guess no one else cares about this poll.  My vote, by the way, is for Queen Rock Montreal, which I recently purchased.  Sound quality is great, and I like the songs from The Game, as well as the '70s material.  Apparently, it is from the same tour as Live at the Bowl, but the Montreal show happened before the release of Hot Space, so it had fewer songs from that album.  For my money, that is a good thing. 
 
Unfortunately, the only Queen live album I have listened to in its entirety is Live at the Bowl.
 
cornfedhick said:
As you are the forum's resident Queen expert/enthusiast, I'm glad you responded, Perun.  I guess no one else cares about this poll.  My vote, by the way, is for Queen Rock Montreal, which I recently purchased.  Sound quality is great, and I like the songs from The Game, as well as the '70s material.  Apparently, it is from the same tour as Live at the Bowl, but the Montreal show happened before the release of Hot Space, so it had fewer songs from that album.  For my money, that is a good thing. 

I remember reading they simply cut the Hot Space tracks out, because the album itself didn't do too well. After all, it does feature the no. 1 hit Under Pressure.
 
I can't vote because I've only listened to Live Killers. As for Live After Death being Maiden's "it" album, I've heard from several other Metalheads that Live at Donington is a much better album. Given I haven't heard any except LAD and RIR I can't confirm such claim, but it seems to be a rather wide spread opinion.

Back to Queen though... I just need more of them. 
 
Onhell said:
As for Live After Death being Maiden's "it" album, I've heard from several other Metalheads that Live at Donington is a much better album.

(At the risk of hijacking my own thread...)  That is just crazy. 

See the poll and accompanying thread addressing that very issue: http://forum.maidenfans.com/index.php?topic=7093.0.  It's not even close.  Note, however, the commendable showing of Rock In Rio in the poll. 

Again, back to Queen...
 
Back
Top