Metallica Survivor 2013: Results Thread - Fade to Black wins!

[MrK]

Thanks for hosting!

Not surprising results, but not very satisfying.

 

[Collin]

I'm pretty pleased I guess. Justice should've made the top 10.
Just a heads up, I'm starting the Megadeth survivor tomorrow. so get listening people.

 

[Moon Child]

Thanks for hosting!

I guess I can say I'm pretty satisfied with the results but at the same time, theres some songs that should have made it higher.

 

[MrK]

I'm pretty pleased I guess. Justice should've made the top 10.
Just a heads up, I'm starting the Megadeth survivor tomorrow. so get listening people.

Just finished Youthanasia, trying to get through everything as I knew this day was coming!

 

[Ariana]

Absolutely satisfied. Fade to Black wins, which means that the world's order has been maintained.
Thanks for hosting, Mosh!

 

[Unknown One]

Fade to Black and Creeping Death at #1 and #2 is awesome. I also have One at like #4 so seeing it third is also good. And as much as I don't like Puppets, I was still expecting it to be up there so I'm fine with that. The only song that definitely doesn't deserve to be here is Seek and Destroy and I would have liked to have seen Ride the Lightning, Disposable Heroes and All Nightmare Long make the top 10, with Four Horseman being higher. However, overall the list is fine.

 

[Detective Beauregard]

Not satisfied. My personal top 10 would look quite different (in no particular order):

- Blackened
- Bleeding Me
- Fixxxer
- Harvester of Sorrow
- No Leaf Clover
- Orion
- Sad But True
- The Unforgiven
- The Unforgiven III
- Until it Sleeps

 

[Forostar]

Thanks for hosting! I think Horsemen should have ended up much higher but for the rest I am satisfied.

 

[The Flash]

Thanks for hosting! Not satisfied since Ktulu didn't make the Top 10.

 

[Black Wizard]

Just a heads up, I'm starting the Megadeth survivor tomorrow. so get listening people.

I'm not satisfied with the result. Puppets and Horsemen should have been top two. #farce

 

[Brigantium]

Cheers for hosting, Mosh! We don't need a tiebreak on overall opinion of the results, do we?

 

[Detective Beauregard]

I said this earlier at some point during this survivor, but I'm not happy that all of the top 10 are from the band's first four albums. Is it surprising? Not at all. But their later albums (excluding St. Anger, of course) have some amazing, well-written material on there that, in my opinion, had a lot more heart put into it than the likes of Battery or Creeping Death.

As for Kill 'Em All, don't even get me started. I don't think there's one song on that entire album that would've made my top 20. Or top 30, or probably even top 40.

 

[MrK]

Now, I do agree with you, but of all the songs you could hate on you chose Battery and Creeping Death. No, sir.