Iced Earth rocks, although Iron Maiden still occupies #1 for me. I chose my name as an alteration from Birth of the Wicked.
For a while my favourite album was Something Wicked This Way Comes(hence my name), but since I can't decide anymore I think my three favourite are probably Burnt Offerings, Something Wicked This Way Comes and The Dark Saga. Besides the studio albums, I think Alive in Athens is one of the best live albums I've heard. You can hear the crowd, but it never overpowers the band and Matt Barlow sings great.
If I had to pick some favourite songs, here's how I'd choose from each album...
Iced Earth: Iced Earth, When The Night Falls(the version on AiA without the long acoustic intro is great)
Night of the Stormrider: Travel In Stygian, Pure Evil(awesome intro)
Burnt Offerings: Burnt Offerings, Brainwashed, Dante's Inferno
The Dark Saga: The Hunter(obviously!), Vengeance Is Mine, Slave To The Dark
Something Wicked This Way Comes: The Trilogy(of course), Burning Times, Watching Over Me
Horror Show: Damien, Dragon's Child, Dracula
The Glorious Burden: Hold At All Costs, High Water Mark(this album seems uninteresting to me so far besides these songs)
I've read a bunch on them and Jon Schaffer's story is pretty amazing. I never read it directly in an interview, but forum chatter was saying he used to sleep in abandoned houses when he was 15 and so many lineup changes.
I think their best singer was definitely Matt Barlow though. Too bad he left.
Woo. That was a lot, but hey you said talk about Iced Earth.