Search results

#5 - The Angel And The Gambler #4 - Age Of Innocence #3 - From Here To Eternity #2 - Wasting Love ... and without shadow of doubt at dead last: #1 - Fear Is The Key

100% Agreed. Not so much agreed.

Iron Maiden to Seventh Son. :D Now seriously... if I had to pick 3 it would be their last three from the 80's. Pity it isn't four, so I could add Piece Of Mind.

Montségur These Colors Don't Run The Talisman PS: 3 is not enough. I'll make it 5 and add FTGOG and WTWWB.

... WTF? Is this a trick question? POM, of course!

Two great songs, hard pick. When it comes to cons (minor details but since it's a close call...), The Wicker Man has the blatant rip off of Running Wild. On the other hand, 2MTM's initial riff is a tad bit too generic. Hey, don't get me wrong: once the bass makes the first doodle and the vocals...

You must be nuts indeed... AMOLAD is a monster of an album and I love it. But... compared with SEVENTH SON???? Nah. Not that it's miles away but still Seventh Son IMO is a different league.

Not the worst but the least brilliant: IMO it's their debut. And to make one thing clear: Not only do I think this is an album with zero fillers, it features one of my top 10 Maiden songs in Phantom Of The Opera. The Number Of The Beast is a close second place. But then again filler material...

If I was to order all songs from these four albums in a Tier list regarding my preferences, it would be something along these lines: Tier S (masterpieces) Sign Of The Cross Man On The Edge Tier A (excellent) Tailgunner Bring Your Daughter To The Slaughter Be Quick Or Be Dead Afraid To Shoot...

Agreed, yet when it comes to repetition, it's not that much of a difference IMO. It's true it doesn't feature any TAATG or DLTTEOAS... but there are some tracks that go full Nascar effect, especially Dream Of Mirrors, the title track. And yup... Let's not mention plagiarism because there's not...

My pachyderm friend... I'm curious to know: If you were forced at gun point to pick one of these albums, which would be your decision? ... And I don't want an answer like "Screw it.. pull the trigger!" :D

It's curious how similar our takes are when it comes to each album's standouts. Even more curious is how a couple of discordances in taste make each of our votes vote tilt in the opposite direction. A ) Fear Of The Dark: To be fair, the tracks I like from FOTD are five of the six songs you...

Two cool tracks. I mean, no standouts but by no means fillers IMO. I like Mother Of Mercy a bit more though.

The X Factor... and it's not even close.

Without having TATG available I'll have to pick a lesser tune. :p Ridiculously great list, with special focus on tracks like Phantom Of The Opera, Revelations, To Tame A Land, Powerslave, Alexander The Great, SSOASS and Infinite Dreams. But who am I fooling? It doesn't matter how good of a...

It's a pity The Angel And The Gambler only came out 6 years later. It would dominate this poll. :D

IMO Chains is ok, Warrior and Apparition not quite. As for the other one:

I really like both albums but, overall, The Final Frontier is not only more cohesive, IMO its highs are higher. First and foremost, the only track I really dislike from both records is Hooks In You. Then there's lots of what I consider to be excellent tunes, with The Talisman and When The Wild...