Search results

  1. Pibroch_Whistler

    The Final Frontier: individual album judgement by yours truly

    whilst listening to "The Mercenary", "The Assassin" and "The Apparition" (among many other "The ..." Maiden tracks), I often imagine that the Mercenary, the Assassin, and The Apparition are sailing at sea (and thus they become sea-faring epics also!) The Unbeliever never sets sail though - for...
  2. Pibroch_Whistler

    Fates Warning + Arch / Matheos

    Parallels is probably my 2nd favorite Fates album after Spectre Within - although I sometimes rate Disconnected and FWX higher than Parallels (the lyrics of the first two FW albums of the 2000's always hit me in the gut)
  3. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Maiden blasphemy

    As blasphemous as I can be (but its the truth): 7th Son is not in my top 10 Maiden albums list (love Moonchild and the Title Track though - both are in my Top 25 Maiden songs of all time)
  4. Pibroch_Whistler

    Fates Warning + Arch / Matheos

    enjoying the punchy quality of the drums on the first single "Scars" (sounds a bit too "in the pocket" to be a Jarzombek drum performance?), but the song hasn't connected too deeply with me yet (currently on listen #2)
  5. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Top 10 songs of any band you want

    The Ladder is mostly excellent all the way through - perhaps best of all, the band sounds incredibly happy and the performances are spirited throughout. in some ways, it plays like a 90125 for the late 1990's- with bits of 70's Yes thrown in for good measure. There's also a series of strong...
  6. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Top 10 songs of any band you want

    Yes 1: Awaken 2: Perpetual Change 3: Yours Is No Disgrace 4: Roundabout 5 Homeworld (The Ladder) 6: Changes 7: Sound Chaser 8: Machine Messiah 9: Turn of the Century 10: The Revealing Science of God (Dance of the Dawn)
  7. Pibroch_Whistler

    The Final Frontier: individual album judgement by yours truly

    didn't the sailors in Rime die of fecal-borne illness (from Albatross poop) while the sailors in The Talisman either died of dehydration (10 days without water), monstrous waves lashing them into the water, or from the scurvy (as our narrator supposedly succumbed to)?
  8. Pibroch_Whistler

    Adrian Smith

    I'm a relatively new poster here - nice to see that others speak sarcasm here :D
  9. Pibroch_Whistler

    Adrian Smith

    would be interesting to hear Janick give a go at H's solo in SIASL
  10. Pibroch_Whistler

    Dream Theater

    would be interesting to see a Tiermaker listing Prog-Rock albums by the number of naked butts on the front cover
  11. Pibroch_Whistler

    I haven't rated an Iron Maiden song lower than a 6 yet

    I haven't rated an Iron Maiden song lower than a 6 yet
  12. Pibroch_Whistler

    Top 3 studio albums from any band

    Jethro Tull: Heavy Horses/Songs From The Wood (can't separate these two masterpieces) Stand Up/Benefit (also can't separate these two) Van Halen: Van Halen II Fair Warning 5150 Obsequiae Obsequiae has only 3 full-length albums, but they're all excellent - a slight dropoff in greatness from...
  13. Pibroch_Whistler

    Top 3 studio albums from any band

    good XTC picks (I'd probably sub in Drums and Wires for Nonsuch, but to be fair I haven't really given enough good listens to Nonsuch). XTC is underrated by hard rock/metal bands - quite a bit of power in their progressions at times Black Sea is definitely a banger
  14. Pibroch_Whistler

    Caught Somewhere In Time

    truly breathtaking cover.
  15. Pibroch_Whistler

    Iron Maiden studio album 17 rumours and speculations

    Sweden should be on for sure
  16. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Maiden blasphemy

    Coming Home = Fantastic Chorus from the reunion era I've also been quite partial to These Colours Don't Run lately also
  17. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Top 10 songs of any band you want

    interesting to note that we both have only 2 Ozzy-era tunes in our top 10 list.
  18. Pibroch_Whistler

    Your Top 10 songs of any band you want

    Black Sabbath: 1: The Sign of The Southern Cross 2: Lonely Is The Word 3 Falling off the Edge of the World 4: Heaven and Hell 5: Children of the Sea 6: Wheels of Confusion 7: Anno Mundi 8: Die Young 9: Country Girl 10: Megalomania
  19. Pibroch_Whistler

    Starblind

    Dig that line a lot - many of the lyrics are anti-religion (which certainly deserve some scorn/ridicule) but its nice to see that the citizenry/governments are left out
  20. Pibroch_Whistler

    Random album reviews

    I don't think of listened to more than 2 or 3 Test For Echo songs in the last TEN years. I've always liked Carve Away the Stone - and oddly enough Colour of Right is a tune that I come back to. So many songs sound like the band is just fiddling around, dialing things in so to speak. Much more...
Back
Top