Search results

  1. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    But if Thomas had made that other save, there would not have been overtime at all.  Besides, the save before that was of equal importance to continuing the game.  A better goalie will make more saves, given the same quality of shots, then a worse goalie.  I don't know why'd you choose the latter...
  2. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    But something like 85 % of hockey is played within two goals.  Nearly every save is a big save.  The only time that this argument comes up is when the goalie in question is sub-par.  When is it not preferable to make a save over not making a save?  Are there goaltenders who deliberately let in...
  3. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Go back in time to a dark and primitive February 2010, and you'd see plenty of journalists calling for Fleury to start in the medal round because of his "clutch" performances.  It's amazing what a Stanley Cup will do for you reputation as a goalie, even if you didn't do that much to deserve it...
  4. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    What?  Miller's played well this playoffs.  It's Fleury and Luongo.
  5. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Here's a question for you: there are two goalies in this year's playoffs, who've played behind rosters with strong defence and superstars.  They have identical stats and identical records so far this year.  Both have played poorly in big game situations in the past.  But one's considered...
  6. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Fuhr was dead average for his career in terms of save percentage (0.887, with a league average of 0.887 during that time), with much of his career spent behind strong defensive teams like the Oilers and the Blues.  You shouldn't get into the Hockey Hall of Fame by being average. 
  7. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    "He rode a hot team" is massively underrating the Oilers.  He played behind what was comparatively the strongest team since the Original Six teams, and a team whose defence has long been unfairly maligned. I don't know as much about '80s goalies; simply put, a lot of them flat out sucked, and...
  8. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Glenn Anderson didn't deserve it.  Neither did Fuhr.
  9. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    I think Bure should absolutely get in.  My criteria for a Hall of Famer is simple: was he, for a given period of time (let's say at least 5 years), the best or near best at his position?  Absolutely.  Bure was one of the most deadly snipers for decidedly less than great teams.  In every season...
  10. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    When does he become eligible?  2014?  If this is Hasek's last year, I would think he gets in before Selanne. Also, if by some cosmic injustice Pavel Bure doesn't make it to the Hall by then, I'd put Bure before Selanne as well.
  11. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Don't know if he's a first ballot HOFer, but he deserves to be in there.
  12. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Luongo.  The Flyers brought back Leighton expressly to give them options, and they already indicated that they were completely fine with replacing the starting goalie after a single game.
  13. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    That's possible, but there's been no indication of that. For the record, Schneider's an excellent goalie, and put up equally good numbers as Luongo.  It is just a strange decision.  It's been clear that Luongo is the starter, and it seems bizarre to yank him after a game where everyone played...
  14. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    I don't understand this at all.
  15. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Nah, Potvin's worse.
  16. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    I hate Potvin.  He's a terrible announcer.
  17. GuineaPig

    Lady Gaga: "Nicko is a Sexy Beast!"

    Is it really that hard to believe?  It's not like she's professing her love for Cryptopsy.  Maiden's accessible and catchy.
  18. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Vezina finalists are Thomas, Rinne, and Luongo.  About right.  Probably would've switched in Hiller for Luongo.
  19. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    Nothing wrong with the Semin goal.
  20. GuineaPig

    Official Hockey discussion thread

    I think that series will go to 7, with San Jose pulling off the victory.
Back
Top