Bruce Dickinson

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
Ruflux said:
I've listened to it once and I have no desire to return to it. I've given albums like VXI or St. Anger multiple shots in comparison. I think the biggest sin Mandrake commits is simply being boring and uninteresting. It's not bad enough to hate with passion, but it's far from being good enough to remember. It just kind of is. I'd rather it wasn't.
Click to expand...
I'd say that's true for media in general. If something, wether we're talking music, tv shows, books, games or movies, is good? Great, that's awesome! If it's genuinely bad? There's fun to be had by picking it apart, looking for plot holes, pointing out the issues in the recording, stuff like that. It elicits some kind of emotional response. But if it's boring? There's nothing to praise, nothing to "hate on" (for lack of a better term). It just ends up forgotten rather soon.

I don't mind "bad" media; those can still be entertaining in some way. Boring though? That's just a waste.
 
Listened to Mandrake twice. Some decent stuff, some terribly generic stuff too.
Kalata said:
Wow, I don't think I can call any album of my favorite bands that.
Click to expand...
Why not? Just because it's made by them? A turd is a turd. It does not make the great albums of the favourite band any worse, so I have no problems to admit if my fave band did a turd. Maiden is the band example. One of my fave bands of all time, but they did weak albums.
So did Bruce solo. Tattooed, Skunkworks and Mandrake all differ in quality, but none of them is good. Mandrake migth still be the least bad of them, though.
 
Mandrake sounds to me like it was finished too hurriedly. I hope he will not make the same mistake again, now that he already releases a new album in 2027 again.
 
Eddie's Uncle said:
Listened to Mandrake twice. Some decent stuff, some terribly generic stuff too.

Why not? Just because it's made by them? A turd is a turd. It does not make the great albums of the favourite band any worse, so I have no problems to admit if my fave band did a turd. Maiden is the band example. One of my fave bands of all time, but they did weak albums.
So did Bruce solo. Tattooed, Skunkworks and Mandrake all differ in quality, but none of them is good. Mandrake migth still be the least bad of them, though.
Click to expand...
Sonata is the only song I go back to Mandrake for now and to an extent Afterglow. Yes two of the most unpopular songs on this forum but Sonatas melody is something.
 
Mandrake project was better that I expected and worse than I wanted it to be. Overall it was an ok album, good enough for me to wait for another one. I like almost all songs but it always feel like compilation/demo/collectors album, hope that next album will be better.
 
Ruflux said:
I think the biggest sin Mandrake commits is simply being boring and uninteresting. It's not bad enough to hate with passion, but it's far from being good enough to remember. It just kind of is. I'd rather it wasn't.
Click to expand...
The guitar playing is really subpar, Bruce delivers, but uninteresting overall(!) and even boring (some songs, ok) or not good enough to remember for a Bruce solo album... wow.
Yax said:
I think it's a decent record, but certainly a disappointment. I had hoped for a record of the ToS quality level (I certainly didn't expect TCW or AoB, so that one is purely on you). But it's clearly a mash of finished songs and semi-finished songs. It's more of a far-along demo than a studio record to me.
Click to expand...
DorotheaMe said:
Mandrake sounds to me like it was finished too hurriedly. I hope he will not make the same mistake again, now that he already releases a new album in 2027 again.
Click to expand...
dickinson1978 said:
For me its an albumwith ideas and song writtren in their free time. And they put it on a record.
Click to expand...
Thisx3.
Eddie's Uncle said:
Why not? Just because it's made by them? A turd is a turd. It does not make the great albums of the favourite band any worse, so I have no problems to admit if my fave band did a turd. Maiden is the band example. One of my fave bands of all time, but they did weak albums.
So did Bruce solo. Tattooed, Skunkworks and Mandrake all differ in quality, but none of them is good. Mandrake migth still be the least bad of them, though.
Click to expand...
Because it's my favorite artist and no song is that weak or unlistenable. Every solo album of his is solid, good, great, interesting and different. Tattooed and Skunkworks are definitely good albums for their styles.
Batman said:
Mandrake project was better that I expected and worse than I wanted it to be. Overall it was an ok album, good enough for me to wait for another one. I like almost all songs but it always feel like compilation/demo/collectors album, hope that next album will be better.
Click to expand...
Interesting take on things, songs from different writing sessions can do this. More than half of the album is good imo. I can say: different than I expected, and worse different than I wanted it to be. The 2 guitars can make the difference and elevate especially longer songs.
Eddie's Uncle said:
Listened to Mandrake twice. Some decent stuff, some terribly generic stuff too.
Click to expand...
Generic stuff? Rain, Mistress, Face?
Belshazzar said:
Broken and Silver Wings are better than anything on Mandrake, and one of them is another song about planes.
Click to expand...
Two of his best solo songs overall.
 
Last edited:
Belshazzar said:
Broken and Silver Wings are better than anything on Mandrake, and one of them is another song about planes.
Click to expand...
I was vaguely aware of Silver Wings but never really gave it a chance until they started playing it on the radio post-Mandrake release and I have to admit, it's not a half-bad tune that. They should play it live honestly, since AFAIK the only time it got played was in '02 and the potato-quality mic-clipped-to-hell footage from that era isn't exactly enticing.
 
Eddie's Uncle said:
So pretty much what EVERY band does which is not full-time professional. And still many of them do better.
Click to expand...
I mean it SOUNDS like this. Exactly what they said how it was recorded. During years and i think they used the ideas they have and thats all.face in the mirror ( i cant remember the song title ) sounds like a song from years ago.
 
DorotheaMe said:
Mandrake sounds to me like it was finished too hurriedly. I hope he will not make the same mistake again, now that he already releases a new album in 2027 again.
Click to expand...
I don’t mind the Mandrake Project. I don’t think there are any terrible songs on the album. My only frustration is you can hear that Bruce used different vocal takes from over the course of 25 years. It is really obvious which takes were done pre and post cancer (just listen for the lisp in the new verse of Eternity). I wish he would have just re-recorded all the vocals. That would have given the album a more consistent sound and feel.
 
redandtheblack92 said:
Sonata is the only song I go back to Mandrake for now and to an extent Afterglow. Yes two of the most unpopular songs on this forum but Sonatas melody is something.
Click to expand...
I couldnt remember the song. But for me sounds like a pop/ indie song from 90s. And 9 minutes? I feel that album hasnt been worked like CW or AOB and maybe like TOS too and they were in different places. Dont know. I remember listening to it and the next song was boring,and the next boring. And so till the end
 
MindRuler said:
One of Bruce´s greatest songs never appeared on a studio album! Yes, as a bonustrack on a remastered version but still...
The Breeding House
Click to expand...
For his first couple of albums the best or most interesting songs are found in the bonus tracks or B sides in my opinion. Yeah, Tears is the exception, but stuff like Darkness Be My Friend, Fire Child, the two No Way Outs, hell even weird experimental stuff like Tibet or dumb fun stuff like Cadillac Gas Mask; I prefer those to anything on TM and BTP (again, with the exception of Tears, though even there I prefer the First Bit, Long Bit, Last Bit version to the album version).
 
Vaenyr said:
For his first couple of albums the best or most interesting songs are found in the bonus tracks or B sides in my opinion. Yeah, Tears is the exception, but stuff like Darkness Be My Friend, Fire Child, the two No Way Outs, hell even weird experimental stuff like Tibet or dumb fun stuff like Cadillac Gas Mask; I prefer those to anything on TM and BTP (again, with the exception of Tears, though even there I prefer the First Bit, Long Bit, Last Bit version to the album version).
Click to expand...
The only song i remember that is a bside and its good is ghost of cain.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top