Tournament Of Short Songs: Phase 1, Round 15

Vote for 1 or 2 of your FAVORITE songs:


  • Total voters
    10
  • Poll closed .

Night Prowler

Customer Deathcycle Manager
Staff member
You can find the rules, list of songs and YouTube playlist of all songs in this thread.
I'll also put a link for each new round there and the thread is stickied so that it's easier to find.

Edguy - Key To My Fate
Gamma Ray - Afterlife
Iron Savior - Riding On Fire
Nightwish - The Phantom Of The Opera
Sabaton - Carolus Rex
 
Great round here.

Edguy - love this band and this song. This gets my vote.
Gamma Ray - like the band but this song I find unremarkable.
Iron Savior - don't know the band so well but decent song. Decent however won't cut it ... I rank this higher than Gamma Ray at least.
Nightwish - fair song. They have much better.
Sabaton - average Sabaton, good enough for my other vote.
 
Phantom and Carolus. Shame to lose the first two, though, I'd happily keep them ahead of some of my choices in other rounds.
 
tumblr_m0cdbrqqfb1rqfhi2o1_500.gif
 
Good friend is always telling me I need to give Edguy a serious try. This song is a good reason to do that. Very nice.
The Gamma Ray was a similar kind of song, not as good.
The Iron Saviour track is pretty by-the-numbers power metal
Nightwish is delightfully cheesy
Sabaton with another fun track.
— fun round all-around.
Tough not vote for Sabaton, but I know they will get support on this forum, so Edguy and Nightwish.
 
Edguy was awesome. I'll have to check them out more. I got some major Queensryche vibes but it wasn't a clone in the way Crimson Glory was.
Gamma Ray was OK. I'm not sure why it got chosen, they have a lot of much stronger material.
Iron Saviour was really bland. Everything I hear from this band is so bland and without any musical identity, they never do anything original.
Nightwish was fun but not very great.
Sabaton was great. I can see this song going far.

Gonna go Sabaton and Edguy.
 
Mosh, I think you are a bit hard on Iron Savior (without "u" ;-) )here. Hope you don't mind that I "defend" them a bit, or at least explain what I like about this song.

Bland? It has a great instrumental piece and chorus. And I have heard worse singers in this genre. The drums by Thomen Stauch are absolutely top notch.
Also, I do not find the musical identity argument that accurate (or fair). Piet Sielck was involved in an early incarnation of Helloween (before they had that name), so in a way you can say he co-shaped identities of other bands. I have a problem with some later Iron Savior songs since they sounds too much like Priest (in an unoriginal manner), but especially songs like Riding On Fire, that is the kind of metal of their "own" that I want to hear from this band. This song is from the debut album, from 1997. Basically it's Sielck's first real full album that he did. Before he worked as a producer and engineer with various bands (e.g. Blind Guardian) in the studio (also providing backing vocals and such). I wouldn't know what other sort of metal I would expect from someone with his background and taste, making his debut.

This is one of the faster Iron Savior songs, and I honestly find it very captivating and melodic (melodies are important, aren't they?) metal. It's fast, yes (for some reason I feel that speed works against the taste of some people on this forum), but the song still stands firm. The timing of the vocals, the solos, all in order. Those harmonies in that instrumental break are so menacing that they sound like riffs. There's also a calm intermezzo with acoustic guitars.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top