Led Zeppelin Survivor finished: Final report
- Thread starter SinisterMinisterX
- Start date
Re: Led Zeppelin Survivor FINAL BATTLE: SIBLY vs Achilles (Nov 1-3)
Oh thank you thank you thank you!
Not because I agree with your vote (which I don't
), but because you broke the tie.
I really have no idea what to do if this ends up tied tomorrow...
cornfedhick said:
Oh thank you thank you thank you!
Not because I agree with your vote (which I don't
), but because you broke the tie.I really have no idea what to do if this ends up tied tomorrow...
____no5
Free Man
Re: Led Zeppelin Survivor FINAL BATTLE: SIBLY vs Achilles (Nov 1-3)
As usual ; You make another round, and if it ends up tied again, your vote counts for two.
More people got involved here and I like it!! Seven whole votes, it must be a record here
At last, it's starting to get interesting this poll -at the very end*, but yet better than never.
*As soon as it's born it's dying
As usual ; You make another round, and if it ends up tied again, your vote counts for two.
More people got involved here and I like it!! Seven whole votes, it must be a record here
At last, it's starting to get interesting this poll -at the very end*, but yet better than never.
*As soon as it's born it's dying
Led Zeppelin Survivor Champion:
Achilles Last Stand
Achilles Last Stand
The top ten Led Zeppelin songs:
1. Achilles Last Stand
2. Since I've Been Loving You
3. Nobody's Fault But Mine
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
6. Dazed And Confused
7. Heartbreaker / Living Loving Maid
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. The Song Remains The Same
10. Travelling Riverside Blues
Results by album:
Rank. Song (Number of rounds survived)
Led Zeppelin (1969)
1. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You (35)
2. Dazed And Confused (34)
3. Good Times Bad Times (10)
4 (tie). Your Time Is Gonna Come (3)
4 (tie). Communication Breakdown (3)
6. Black Mountain Side (1)
7 (tie). You Shook Me (0)
7 (tie). I Can't Quit You Baby (0)
7 (tie). How Many More Times (0)
Led Zeppelin II (1969)
1. Heartbreaker / Living Loving Maid (33)
2. Ramble On (21)
3. Whole Lotta Love (16)
4. The Lemon Song (5)
5. Thank You (4)
6 (tie). What Is And What Should Never Be (0)
6 (tie). Moby Dick (0)
6 (tie). Bring It On Home (0)
Led Zeppelin III (1970)
1. Since I've Been Loving You (36)
2 (tie). Immigrant Song (5)
2 (tie). Celebration Day (5)
4. Gallows Pole (4)
5 (tie). Friends (3)
5 (tie). Tangerine (3)
7 (tie). Out On The Tiles (2)
7 (tie). That's The Way (2)
9. Bron-Y-Aur Stomp (1)
10. Hats Off To (Roy) Harper (0)
Led Zeppelin IV (1971)
1. Stairway To Heaven (30)
2. Going To California (6)
3. Black Dog (3)
4 (tie). Rock And Roll (1)
4 (tie). Misty Mountain Hop (1)
4 (tie). When The Levee Breaks (1)
7 (tie). The Battle Of Evermore (0)
7 (tie). Four Sticks (0)
Houses Of The Holy (1973)
1. The Song Remains The Same (23)
2. Over The Hills And Far Away (10)
3. The Rain Song (6)
4. The Crunge (4)
5 (tie). Dancing Days (3)
5 (tie). No Quarter (3)
5 (tie). The Ocean (3)
8. D'yer Maker (0)
Physical Graffiti (1975)
1. In My Time Of Dying (19)
2. Kashmir (14)
3. The Rover (9)
4. Houses Of The Holy (4)
5 (tie). Ten Years Gone (3)
5 (tie). Sick Again (3)
7 (tie). Custard Pie (2)
7 (tie). Trampled Under Foot (2)
7 (tie). In The Light (2)
10 (tie). Bron-Yr-Aur (1)
10 (tie). Down By The Seaside (1)
10 (tie). Night Flight (1)
10 (tie). Boogie With Stu (1)
10 (tie). Black Country Woman (1)
15. The Wanton Song (0)
Presence (1976)
1. Achilles Last Stand (20)
2. Nobody's Fault But Mine (18)
3 (tie). For Your Life (1)
3 (tie). Royal Orleans (1)
3 (tie). Tea For One (1)
6 (tie). Candy Store Rock (0)
6 (tie). Hots On For Nowhere (0)
In Through The Out Door (1979)
1. All My Love (3)
2. South Bound Saurez (2)
3 (tie). In The Evening (1)
3 (tie). Fool In The Rain (1)
5 (tie). Hot Dog (0)
5 (tie). Carouselambra (0)
5 (tie). I'm Gonna Crawl (0)
Coda (1982)
1 (tie). We're Gonna Groove (1)
1 (tie). Wearing And Tearing (1)
2 (tie). Poor Tom (0)
2 (tie). Walter's Walk (0)
2 (tie). Ozone Baby (0)
2 (tie). Darlene (0)
2 (tie). Bonzo's Montreux (0)
Non-album songs
1. Travelling Riverside Blues (3)
2. Hey Hey What Can I Do (2)
Results by series:
Series 1:
11. Black Mountain Side
12 (tie). You Shook Me
12 (tie). I Can't Quit You Baby
12 (tie). How Many More Times
12 (tie). What Is And What Should Never Be
12 (tie). Moby Dick
12 (tie). Bring It On Home
Series 2:
11 (tie). The Lemon Song
11 (tie). Friends
11 (tie). Tangerine
14 (tie). Thank You
14 (tie). Out On The Tiles
14 (tie). That's The Way
17 (tie). Your Time Is Gonna Come
17 (tie). Communication Breakdown
17 (tie). Bron-Y-Aur Stomp
20. Hats Off To (Roy) Harper
Series 3:
11 (tie). Immigrant Song
11 (tie). Celebration Day
11 (tie). Rock And Roll
11 (tie). Misty Mountain Hop
11 (tie). When The Levee Breaks
16 (tie). Gallows Pole
16 (tie). The Battle Of Evermore
16 (tie). Four Sticks
Series 4:
11 (tie). Going To California
11 (tie). The Crunge
13 (tie). Dancing Days
13 (tie). No Quarter
13 (tie). The Ocean
16. Good Times Bad Times
17. Black Dog
18. D'yer Ma'ker
Series 5:
11. Over The Hills And Far Away
12. Houses Of The Holy
13 (tie). Whole Lotta Love
13 (tie). Ten Years Gone
13 (tie). Sick Again
16 (tie). Custard Pie
16 (tie). Trampled Under Foot
16 (tie). In The Light
19 (tie). The Rain Song
19 (tie). Bron-Yr-Aur
19 (tie). Down By The Seaside
19 (tie). Night Flight
19 (tie). Boogie With Stu
19 (tie). Black Country Woman
25. The Wanton Song
Series 6:
11. The Rover
12. Ramble On
13 (tie). For Your Life
13 (tie). Royal Orleans
13 (tie). Tea For One
16 (tie). Candy Store Rock
16 (tie). Hots On For Nowhere
Series 7:
11. All My Love
12. South Bound Suarez
13 (tie). In The Evening
13 (tie). Fool In The Rain
15 (tie). Hot Dog
15 (tie). Carouselambra
15 (tie). I'm Gonna Crawl
Series 8:
11. Hey Hey What Can I Do
12 (tie). We're Gonna Groove
12 (tie). Wearing And Tearing
14 (tie). Kashmir
14 (tie). Poor Tom
14 (tie). Walter's Walk
14 (tie). Ozone Baby
14 (tie). Darlene
14 (tie). Bonzo's Montreux
11. Black Mountain Side
12 (tie). You Shook Me
12 (tie). I Can't Quit You Baby
12 (tie). How Many More Times
12 (tie). What Is And What Should Never Be
12 (tie). Moby Dick
12 (tie). Bring It On Home
Series 2:
11 (tie). The Lemon Song
11 (tie). Friends
11 (tie). Tangerine
14 (tie). Thank You
14 (tie). Out On The Tiles
14 (tie). That's The Way
17 (tie). Your Time Is Gonna Come
17 (tie). Communication Breakdown
17 (tie). Bron-Y-Aur Stomp
20. Hats Off To (Roy) Harper
Series 3:
11 (tie). Immigrant Song
11 (tie). Celebration Day
11 (tie). Rock And Roll
11 (tie). Misty Mountain Hop
11 (tie). When The Levee Breaks
16 (tie). Gallows Pole
16 (tie). The Battle Of Evermore
16 (tie). Four Sticks
Series 4:
11 (tie). Going To California
11 (tie). The Crunge
13 (tie). Dancing Days
13 (tie). No Quarter
13 (tie). The Ocean
16. Good Times Bad Times
17. Black Dog
18. D'yer Ma'ker
Series 5:
11. Over The Hills And Far Away
12. Houses Of The Holy
13 (tie). Whole Lotta Love
13 (tie). Ten Years Gone
13 (tie). Sick Again
16 (tie). Custard Pie
16 (tie). Trampled Under Foot
16 (tie). In The Light
19 (tie). The Rain Song
19 (tie). Bron-Yr-Aur
19 (tie). Down By The Seaside
19 (tie). Night Flight
19 (tie). Boogie With Stu
19 (tie). Black Country Woman
25. The Wanton Song
Series 6:
11. The Rover
12. Ramble On
13 (tie). For Your Life
13 (tie). Royal Orleans
13 (tie). Tea For One
16 (tie). Candy Store Rock
16 (tie). Hots On For Nowhere
Series 7:
11. All My Love
12. South Bound Suarez
13 (tie). In The Evening
13 (tie). Fool In The Rain
15 (tie). Hot Dog
15 (tie). Carouselambra
15 (tie). I'm Gonna Crawl
Series 8:
11. Hey Hey What Can I Do
12 (tie). We're Gonna Groove
12 (tie). Wearing And Tearing
14 (tie). Kashmir
14 (tie). Poor Tom
14 (tie). Walter's Walk
14 (tie). Ozone Baby
14 (tie). Darlene
14 (tie). Bonzo's Montreux
Thanks for playing everyone! I'd like to do this one again sometime, since the low turnout really messed things up here. Most of this Survivor was played under the original rules, which weren't good for low-turnout games.
This is a weird-looking top 10. I've never seen one quite like it. No "Whole Lotta Love" (I'm OK with that) and no "Kashmir" (I am most definitely not OK with that, it was my pick for #1!). Still, it's a good top 10.
____no5
Free Man
1. Achilles Last Stand
2. Since I've Been Loving You
3. Nobody's Fault But Mine -->
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You -->
6. Dazed And Confused --->
7. Heartbreaker / Living Loving Maid -->
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. The Song Remains The Same -->
10. Travelling Riverside Blues -->
Interesting Top10, but totally different from mine. A quick one made :
1. Achilles Last Stand
2. Kashmir
3. Since I've Been Loving You
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Going to California
6. No Quarter
7. Gallows Pole
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. Good Times Bad Times
10. When the Levee Breaks
2. Since I've Been Loving You
3. Nobody's Fault But Mine -->
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You -->
6. Dazed And Confused --->
7. Heartbreaker / Living Loving Maid -->
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. The Song Remains The Same -->
10. Travelling Riverside Blues -->
Interesting Top10, but totally different from mine. A quick one made :
1. Achilles Last Stand
2. Kashmir
3. Since I've Been Loving You
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Going to California
6. No Quarter
7. Gallows Pole
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. Good Times Bad Times
10. When the Levee Breaks