IRON MAIDEN ALBUMS SURVIVOR: TIEBREAKER

http://goo.gl/images/jH8bQK

Right on.

 

Ask me in 34 years... I might not even will have listened to Maiden in quite some time, but I'm pretty sure my answer's going to be the same.

Many albums have been "celebrated as a classic," but the popular opinion has its flaws.

For what it's worth, NOTB is probably my least favourite Maiden album, probably even below Killers, Hallowed and Prisoner (and maybe 22AA) notwithstanding.

 

Why would you? Keef Richards definitely won't be...

 

SiT. My granny plays better MIDI than the so called H

 

Definitely SIT.

 

So hard to choose here.
SIT is better, not because of the MIDI, than POM. In my POV.

^The virus called online language.

 

Easily PoM. It's gotten too far to be honest.

 

SiT wants to be like PoM when it grows up and it will never be.

 

When does this tiebreaker end? I don't want to cheer too early again.

 

Apart from the over all sound of SIT which I don't like,
I have only one track from SIT in my top 25 (Alexander at 19), I have two from POM in top 25 (Revelations at 6, Where Eagles Dare at 17) both higher ranked than Alexander.

2 other SIT tracks I rank as very good:
Wasted Years
Stranger in a Strange Land

But 4 POM tracks at very good:
Flight of Icarus
Die with Your Boots On
The Trooper
Still Life

It's not even close, POM is a clear winner in my book.

 

Both of these are better than AMOLAD.

But SiT is worse than PoM.

 

Tiiiiiiiime is not always on my side.
Tiiiiiiiime id not always on my siiiiiide....

 

Really? One of PoM or AMOLAD guaranteed in the top 3 is ridiculous. Especially lacking SiT and BNW.

 

Yep, the newbies have negative opinions on Somewhere in Time and the nineties. Let's hope it changes again, in a while.

 

I don't know if I'm a newbie. But I've been a Maiden fan for 30 years and if POM is kicked out, my top three would be the remaining albums.

SIT is the most overrated album in Maiden's discography.