As you scream into the web of silence...
It is neither.
Bam, nailed it!Hallowed Be Thy Name
Actually, I thought: "all these clues are names"... but that works too!Bam, nailed it!
Clue #1: LooseCannon. - Has been doing the rankings for years and "Hallowed" has almost always won. Going by averages throughout the years, it's still the winner.
Clue #2: CriedWhenBrucieLeft. - The "Hallowed" single came out in Bruce's last year of his first stint with the band. That cover... more fuel for an exit???
Clue #3: Jer. - "Hallowed" is one of the few songs he has given a 10/10 to.
Clue #4: Stardust. - Give "Hallowed" a frickin' 4 for god's sakes!
Clue #5: Onhell. - Opened the "Hallowed" thread in the commentary board.
Clue #6: Diesel 11 & Number 6. - Both of us think that "Hallowed" is a pretty great song but far from the best that Maiden have released.
Clue #7: JudasMyGuide. - He's Catholic, and "Hallowed Be Thy Name" comes from a line in the Lord's Prayer.