Helloween is all over the place on Keeper pt. 1, struggling to string riffs together. Keeper pt. 2 is more developed.
First of all, this is not a battle between Keepers 1 and 2.
And please do not try to make your reasons look like they're objective. Struggling to string riffs together? All over the place? In your head perhaps.
Keepers 1 does not contain weaker songs a la Rise and Fall.