Van Hagar Survivor Finished: Dreams Wins!

[Mosh]

Welcome to Van Hagar survivor 2013!
Rules for Survivors:
If you're new, these games are like the TV show Survivor: vote to eliminate the worst, allowing the best to survive. Always vote for your LEAST favorite songs. On this new forum you have unlimited votes; At the end of a round I'll eliminate the "winners";

We have the 4 Hagar fronted Van Halen albums plus VHIII and 4 bonus tracks. The 4 bonus songs will join with III, but they will be treated as their own album, with two getting promoted.

Lets get this started with 5150 and OU812

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
When It's Love - 2 votes
Source of Infection - 2 votes

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Good Enough - 2 votes
Get Up - 2 votes
Love Walks In - 2 votes
Black and Blue - 2 votes

 

[Night Prowler]

Dammit. I didn't have time to relisten & vote and my favorite Hagar song is already gone

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
AFU - 2 votes
Feels So Good - 2 votes
A Apolitical Blues - 2 votes

For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge joins the battle!

 

[Mosh]

Summer Nights
Inside
Mine All Mine
Sucker
Spanked
In n Out
316

A more rocking album, but also more filler. Has 2 songs that absolutely must be in the top ten though.

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Summer Nights - 2 votes
Inside - 2 votes
Spanked - 3 votes
In "N" Out - 3 votes

 

[Mosh]

Sucker
Pleasure
Mission
316

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Sucker In A Three Piece - 2 votes
Man On A Mission - 2 votes
316 - 2 votes

 

[Mosh]

Why Can't This Be Love
Mine All Mine
Judgement Day
Pleasure Dome

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Judgement Day - 2 votes
Pleasure Dome - 2 votes

 

[Mosh]

Big Fat Money
Strung Out
Not Enough
Doin' Time
Feelin'
Crossing Over

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Big Fat Money - 2 votes
Strung Out - 2 votes
Doin' Time - 2 Votes
Crossing Over - 2 votes

 

[Mosh]

Not Enough
Aftershock
Baluchiterium (Reluctantly)
Feelin'

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Not Enough - 2 votes
Aftershock - 2 votes
Baluchiterium - 2 votes

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Amsterdam
Feelin'
Take Me Back

Van Halen III and the 4 bonus songs have joined the battle!

 

[mckindog]

I guess to vote fairly, I'll have to listen to III again.
Didn't really like any of it, but some was less bad than others.

 

[Mosh]

I had to listen to it again as well. I love the first four Extreme albums but Gary Cherone was never my favorite singer and the attempt at cloning Hagar didn't help that. Less memorable solos by Eddie as well. So it's hard enjoy it as much as the others. I think it's a step up from Balance though, which starts off really strong but is loaded with filler. III is slightly more consistent, I might even call Without You a top ten song, the rest ranges from average to really bad.

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Neworld
Primary
Year To The Day
How Many Say I
Learning to See
It's About Time

Promoted:
Up For Breakfast
Humans Being

 

[Mosh]

Eliminated:
Dirty Water Dog
Fire In The Hole
Josephina