Discussion in 'Forum Games' started by Night Prowler, Oct 12, 2016.
This first 16 song playlist is 2 hr, 31 min long.
Under The Weeping Moon, The Twilight Is My Robe, The Night & The Silent Water, Black Rose Immortal.
The Night & The Silent Water
Black Rose Immortal
Eliminated after Round 18:
The Night & The Silent Water - 5 votes
Under The Weeping Moon - 4 votes
Black Rose Immortal - 4 votes
When - 3 votes
Face In The Snow - 3 votes
Easy choices: Twilight, Ghost, Lotus, Will.
When deserved better.
Will O the Wisp better than Twilight? No. Fucking. Way. Re-fuc-king-DI-culous fellas.
As someone who voted for Ghost of Perdition, IDNRYO.
Eliminated after Round 19:
The Twilight Is My Robe - 6 votes
Cusp Of Eternity - 5 votes
Will O The Wisp - 5 votes
The Lotus Eater - 3 votes
Second group of promoted songs joins the finals!
Master's Apprentices, Grand Conjuration, and Heir Apparent all fulfill the same basic role on their respective albums (the crushing, heavy, demonic song) and though I truly like or love all three, Grand Conjuration is easily the strongest.
WTF is with all of the Demon of the Fall votes? Is this just the "overplayed, overrated" syndrome we love around here? Is this Opeth's "Run to the Hills"?
Great song but something has to go.
MAYH has had a terrible showing overall, which is a shame.
Demon of the Fall is a Top 10 song, at least a borderline Top 10 song.
I think that MAYH taken on its own is a solid piece of music. Demon of the Fall is undoubtedly the strongest track on it, but nothing from this album really stands out compared to the rest of the band's discography. It works as a self-contained unit, but it can't stack up to the greats from the Still Life through Ghost Reveries era.
Mist, Heir, Wilde, Chrysalis.
All of you voting for Demon Of The Fall this early are crazy.
Eliminated after Round 20:
The Wilde Flowers - 5 votes
Chrysalis - 5 votes
In Mist She Was Standing - 4 votes
Demon Of The Fall - 4 votes
Master's Apprentices - 3 votes
Btw, I'm a bit lost as to how the game works. When are Blackwater Park, Harlequin Forest etc coming into the game?
Separate names with a comma.