Megadeth Album Survivor Results

[Collin]

Same rules as my Iron Maiden survivor. Vote for 3

 

[Black Wizard]

Cryptic Writings
Risk
The World Needs a Hero

You might as well have not started with these three.

 

[Collin]

I agree with Risk. That album is terrible. But Cryptic Writings isn't to bad. The World Needs a Hero has some good songs on it.

 

[Night Prowler]

Risk
Th1rt3en
Super Collider

 

[Night Prowler]

Youthanasia and Cryptic Writings worse than last 2? You're kidding.

 

[The Flash]

Cryptic Writings
Risk
The World Needs a Hero

You might as well have not started with these three.

Cryptic Writings is a very good album. At least 3,5/5.

Risk
TH1RT3EN
Super Collider

 

[Mosh]

Need to listen to some of these again, but for now Super Collider is enough.

 

[Unknown One]

I should vote Rust in Peace just to see how flamed I'd get.

 

[Sara]

Super Collider
The World Needs A Hero
13

 

[Black Wizard]

I should vote Rust in Peace just to see how flamed I'd get.

The greatest Thrash album of all time? Not a chance!

I haven't actually listened to 'Super Collider' yet, not that it will go far in the game anyway.

 

[Unknown One]

Well I don't listen to Megadeth much, infact the only full albums I've heard are Peace Sells and Rust in Peace, so won't be voting in this survivor.

 

[Black Wizard]

Well if those two are still around late on then you can vote to keep them in, or just vote for what I vote for.

Listen to more Megadeth though. At least know everything up to and including 'Countdown to Extinction'.

 

[Unknown One]

I thought 13 was well liked? I remember a bunch of people saying they liked it a little bit after the release date.

 

[Mosh]

I liked it when it was new. Haven't heard it since though.

 

[Sara]

"13" has some great songs on it, but overall it's very patchy. It contains some very poor songs, amongst the worst in Megadeth's career, and it's very filler-ish as a whole.

 

[The Flash]

13 is nothing special.

 

[Black Wizard]

It's not, but it's quite good fun at times. I like it.

 

[MrKnickerbocker]

Last three. The songs on Risk may not be very Megadeth, but they sure are more well written than the slow-churned-butter/afterthought-thrash of the last three albums.

 

[Collin]

I'm just gonna say this. Super Collider is bad, but Risk is way worse. Kingmaker and Dance in the Rain were enough to make me not vote for it. However that being said, I voted for Risk and Youthanasia.

 

[Sara]

I'd take "Risk" over "Super Collider" any day of the week! The reason why "Risk" takes such a bashing, is because it's their lightest album overall. But I find the quality of the songwriting on "Risk" to be way above the songwriting on "Super Collider". I love most of what's on "Risk", a couple of songs not-withstanding. Most of what's on "Super Collider" is either terrible at worst, or forgettable at best. Songs like "Dance In The Rain" and "Kingmaker" are very good, and save it from being a complete disaster, but overall, it's the worst collection of songs in Megadeth's career.