1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Album rankings per person

Discussion in 'Commentary Discussion' started by Forostar, Jan 7, 2011.

  1. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Based on the individual album judgements (explanation here) we now can make an overview of all the studio albums, per person. In this topic I'll put all people who have contributed to at least one album judgement.
    People in navy colour have done all albums, and are featured in this post.

    To see the results of the members who contributed but who didn't do all songs yet, see my second post of this thread. Scroll down, or click here. I had to split it up, because this message exceeds the maximum allowed length (20000 characters).

    LooseCannon
    1. Brave New World 8,9
    2. Virtual XI 8,5
    2. The Final Frontier 8,5
    4. The X Factor 8,1
    4. A Matter of Life and Death 8,1
    6. Powerslave 8,0
    6. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,0
    8. Somewhere in Time 7,8
    9. The Number of the Beast 7,3
    10. Iron Maiden 7,2
    11. Piece of Mind 7,1
    12. Killers 6,8
    13. Dance of Death 6,7
    14. No Prayer for the Dying 6,5
    15. Fear of the Dark 5,0

    Eddies Wingman
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,8
    1. Brave New World 8,8
    3. A Matter of Life and Death 8,7
    3. The Final Frontier 8,7
    5. Powerslave 8,6
    6. Somewhere in Time 8,5
    7. Piece of Mind 8,1
    7. The X Factor 8,1
    9. Dance of Death 8,0
    10. The Number of the Beast 7,8
    10. Virtual XI 7,8
    12. Iron Maiden 7,4
    13. Killers 7,2
    14. Fear of the Dark 6,8
    15. No Prayer for the Dying 6,7

    taker64
    1. A Matter of Life and Death 9,3
    2. Brave New World 9,1
    3. Iron Maiden 9,0
    4. The Final Frontier 8,8
    5. Killers 8,7
    6. The Number of the Beast 8,1
    6. Dance of Death 8,1
    8. Somewhere in Time 7,9
    9. Piece of Mind 7,8
    10. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 7,4
    11. Powerslave 6,9
    11. Fear of the Dark 6,9
    13. No Prayer for the Dying 6,6
    14. The X Factor 6,5
    15. Virtual XI 6,3

    mckindog
    1. The Final Frontier 8,8
    2. Somewhere in Time 8,3
    3. Piece of Mind 8,2
    4. Powerslave 8,1
    5. Brave New World 8,0
    6. The Number of the Beast 7,9
    7. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 7,8
    7. A Matter of Life and Death 7,8
    9. Dance of Death 7,6
    10. The X Factor 7,2
    11. Killers 7,1
    11. Virtual XI 7,1
    13. Fear of the Dark 7,0
    14. Iron Maiden 6,9
    15. No Prayer for the Dying 6,1

    Black_Thunder
    1. The Final Frontier 8,8
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 8,4
    3. Brave New World 8,3
    4. Iron Maiden 8,1
    5. The Number of the Beast 7,9
    6. Piece of Mind 7,8
    6. Powerslave 7,8
    6. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 7,8
    9. Dance of Death 7,6
    10. Somewhere in Time 7,4
    11. Killers 6,9
    12. Virtual XI 6,5
    13. The X Factor 6,2
    14. No Prayer for the Dying 5,6
    15. Fear of the Dark 5,4

    Perun
    1. The X Factor 9,7
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 9,1
    3. Virtual XI 8,9
    4. Iron Maiden 8,7
    4. Piece of Mind 8,7
    6. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,6
    6. Brave New World 8,6
    8. Somewhere in Time 8,3
    8. The Final Frontier 8,3
    10. The Number of the Beast 7,8
    11. Killers 7,5
    12. Powerslave 7,3
    13. Dance of Death 7,2
    14. No Prayer for the Dying 6,3
    15. Fear of the Dark 5,6

    Jeffmetal
    1. Powerslave 9,4
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 9,4
    1. Dance of Death 9,4
    4. Piece of Mind 9,3
    4. Somewhere in Time 9,3
    4. Brave New World 9,3
    7. The X Factor 9,1
    8. Killers 9,0
    8. The Final Frontier 9,0
    10.The Number of the Beast 8,8
    11. Virtual XI 8,5
    12. Iron Maiden 8,4
    13. No Prayer for the Dying 8,0
    14. Fear of the Dark 7,9
    15. A Matter of Life and Death 6,9

    maidenhead1996
    1. The Final Frontier 9,1
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 8,9
    3. Powerslave 8,6
    3. Somewhere in Time 8,6
    3. Brave New World 8,6
    6. Piece of Mind 8,4
    7. The X Factor 8,3
    8. The Number of the Beast 8,2
    9. Dance of Death 8,1
    10. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,0
    11. Iron Maiden 7,9
    12. Killers 7,8
    12. Virtual XI 7,8
    14. No Prayer for the Dying 7,5
    15. Fear of the Dark 7,0

    Stallion Duck
    1. Killers 9,3
    1. Virtual XI 9,3
    3. Brave New World 9,0
    4. Powerslave 8,6
    4. The Final Frontier 8,6
    6. Somewhere in Time 8,5
    6. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,5
    8. A Matter of Life and Death 8,4
    9. Piece of Mind 8,2
    10. The Number of the Beast 8,1
    10. Dance of Death 8,1
    12. The X Factor 7,6
    13. No Prayer for the Dying 7,4
    14. Iron Maiden 7,0
    15. Fear of the Dark 4,4

    Fugazi
    1. The Number of the Beast 9,7
    2. Somewhere in Time 9,5
    3. Powerslave 9,4
    3. The Final Frontier 9,4
    5. Piece of Mind 8,8
    6. Brave New World 8,7
    7. The X Factor 8,5
    7. A Matter of Life and Death 8,5
    9. Dance of Death 8,2
    10. Iron Maiden 8,0
    10. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,0
    12. No Prayer for the Dying 7,6
    13. Fear of the Dark 7,3
    14. Killers 7,2
    15. Virtual XI 6,9

    Vap
    1. Brave New World 9,3
    1. A Matter of Life and Death 9,3
    3. Somewhere in Time 9,1
    4. Piece of Mind 8,7
    5. The Number of the Beast 8,6
    5. Powerslave 8,6
    7. Virtual XI 8,5
    7. The Final Frontier 8,5
    9. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,4
    10. The X Factor 8,3
    10. Dance of Death 8,3
    12. Killers 7,7
    13. Iron Maiden 7,0
    14. No Prayer for the Dying 6,4
    15. Fear of the Dark 6,2

    NightProwler666
    1. Brave New World 9,6
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 9,4
    3. Somewhere in Time 9,0
    4. Piece of Mind 8,6
    5. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,4
    5. The Final Frontier 8,4
    7. The Number of the Beast 8,3
    7. Powerslave 8,3
    7. Dance of Death 8,3
    10. Iron Maiden 8,0
    11. The X Factor 7,5
    12. No Prayer for the Dying 7,2
    13. Virtual XI 6,4
    14. Fear of the Dark 6,0
    15. Killers 5,8

    bearfan
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 9,4
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 9,0
    3. Iron Maiden 8,8
    4. The Number of the Beast 8,7
    5. Killers 8,5
    6. Piece of Mind 8,4
    6. Powerslave 8,4
    6. Brave New World 8,4
    9. The Final Frontier 8,3
    10. Somewhere in Time 7,6
    11. Dance of Death 7,6
    12. Virtual XI 7,1
    13. No Prayer for the Dying 7,0
    14. The X Factor 6,6
    15. Fear of the Dark 6,2

    Albie
    1. Killers 8,6
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,6
    3. The Final Frontier 8,5
    4. Virtual XI 8,3
    5. Iron Maiden 8,2
    6. Brave New World 8,1
    6. A Matter of Life and Death 8,1
    8. Powerslave 8,0
    8. The X Factor 8,0
    10. The Number of the Beast 7,6
    10. Dance of Death 7,6
    12. Piece of Mind 7,4
    13. No Prayer for the Dying 7,1
    14. Somewhere in Time 6,9
    15. Fear of the Dark 5,5

    Zare
    1. Somewhere in Time 9,6
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 8,6
    3. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,5
    3. The X Factor 8,5
    5. The Final Frontier 8,4
    6. Powerslave 7,9
    6. Virtual XI 7,9
    8. Piece of Mind 7,6
    9. Killers 7,4
    9. No Prayer for the Dying 7,4
    9. Brave New World 7,4
    12. Dance of Death 7,2
    13. Fear of the Dark 6,6
    14. The Number of the Beast 6,7
    15. Iron Maiden 6,4

    Forostar
    1. Somewhere in Time 9,1
    2. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,9
    3. Powerslave 8,8
    4. The Final Frontier 8,5
    5. A Matter of Life and Death 8,4
    6. No Prayer for the Dying 8,3
    6. The X Factor 8,3
    8. Iron Maiden 8,1
    8. Piece of Mind 8,1
    10. Brave New World 8,0
    11. Killers 7,8
    12. The Number of the Beast 7,7
    13. Fear of the Dark 7,6
    14. Virtual XI 7,4
    15. Dance of Death 7,3


    To see the results of the members who contributed but who didn't do all songs yet, see my second post of this thread. Scroll down, or click here.
     
  2. mckindog

    mckindog Living for Sanctuary from the law Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    THanks Foro.
    I'd just added this the other thread, but I'll move it here.

    My Golden Era scores:
    SIT            8.3
    POM          8.2
    PS            8.1
    NOTB        7.9
    SSOASS    7.8
    Killers        7.1
    Iron Maiden 6.9

    Pretty reflective of what my rankings would have been, I'd say.
     
  3. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    First post of this thread contains the members who did all songs.

    Donner
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 9,3
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 8,4
    3. The Final Frontier 8,3
    3. Iron Maiden 8,3
    5. The X Factor 7,6
    6. Brave New World 7,5
    7. Dance of Death 7,3
    8. No Prayer for the Dying 7,2
    9. Virtual XI 5,9
    10. Fear of the Dark 5,5
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)

    Invader
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,3
    2. The Number of the Beast 8,0
    2. Powerslave 8,0
    2. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,0
    5. Piece of Mind 7,6
    6. No Prayer for the Dying 7,0
    7. Iron Maiden 6,7
    8. Fear of the Dark 6,3
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    national acrobat
    1. Brave New World 7,7
    2. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 7,4
    3. The X Factor 7,2
    4. Virtual XI 7,0
    5. Somewhere in Time 6,6
    6. Dance of Death 5,9
    7. Fear of the Dark 4,3
    8. No Prayer for the Dying 3,6
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000
    1. Piece of Mind 9,1
    2. The Number of the Beast 9,0
    2. Powerslave 9,0
    2. Dance of Death 9,0
    5. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,9
    6. Brave New World 8,6
    7. The X Factor 8,4
    8. No Prayer for the Dying 7,5
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Prowler_108
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,8
    2. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,4
    3. The Number of the Beast 8,2
    4. Killers 7,9
    5. Powerslave 7,6
    6. Fear of the Dark 6,8
    7. Iron Maiden 6,7
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    _____no5
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 9,5
    2. Powerslave 9,1
    3. The Number of the Beast 8,8
    4. Iron Maiden 8,7
    5. Piece of Mind 8,4
    6. Killers 7,9
    7. Somewhere in Time 7,3
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Jonszat
    1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 9,1
    2. Piece of Mind 7,9
    3. Somewhere in Time 7,4
    4. The Number of the Beast 7,3
    5. Iron Maiden 7,2
    6. Powerslave 6,9
    7. Killers 5,6
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Genghis Khan
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,8
    2. Powerslave 8,0
    3. The Number of the Beast 7,3
    4. Killers 7,1
    5. Piece of Mind 6,8
    6. Iron Maiden 6,6
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Unknown One
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,6
    2. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,4
    3. Brave New World 8,0
    4. Piece of Mind 7,8
    5. Dance of Death 7,6
    6. The Number of the Beast 7,2
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    The Mid-Distance Runner
    1. The Final Frontier 9,7
    2. Somewhere in Time 9,0
    2. A Matter of Life and Death 9,0
    4. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 8,1
    4. Dance of Death 8,1
    6. Fear of the Dark 5,8
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)

    czgibson
    1. Powerslave 8,6
    2. Iron Maiden 8,3
    2. The Number of the Beast 8,3
    4. Piece of Mind 8,2
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    wizard
    1. Iron Maiden 8,4
    2. The Number of the Beast 8,1
    3. Killers 7,6
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Murder89
    1. The Number of the Beast 9,7
    2. Iron Maiden 8,9
    3. Killers 8,7
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Ranko
    1. Powerslave 7,5
    2. Piece of Mind 6,9
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Jupz
    1. A Matter of Life and Death 9,0
    2. Dance of Death 7,3
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Rotam
    1. Iron Maiden 7,9
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Vortex
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,9
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Babo 91
    1. Somewhere in Time 8,5
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Onun
    1. The Number of the Beast 7,4
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Mega
    1. Fear of the Dark 6,0
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? A Matter of Life and Death (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Final Frontier (didn't vote for all songs)

    Cosmiceddie
    1. A Matter of Life and Death 7,9
    2. The Final Frontier 7,5
    ?? Iron Maiden (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Killers (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The Number of the Beast (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Piece of Mind (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Powerslave (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Somewhere in Time (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? No Prayer for the Dying (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Fear of the Dark (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? The X Factor (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Virtual XI (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Brave New World (didn't vote for all songs)
    ?? Dance of Death (didn't vote for all songs)
     
  4. Perun

    Perun Climbing like a monkey Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I think I'm through with Seventh Son. 8.6. Looking back, I wish I had given Infinite Dreams a ten, though.
     
  5. Invader

    Invader Ancient Mariner

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Your post shows the differences in voting habits between different members pretty well.  For example, Loosey and Black_Thunder are rather conservative voters (avg. album rating 7,5 and 7,7 respectively) while e.g. Travis is very liberal with giving high ratings (avg. album rating 9).

    Albums that reached no. 1 the most (tied scores count as half for both, excluded everyone that had just one album rated):
    Seventh Son of a Seventh Son: 5.5
    Somewhere in Time: 5.5
    Powerslave: 3
    Piece of Mind: 3
    Iron Maiden: 2.5
    The Number of the Beast: 1
    Killers: 0

    Not that surprising, but another way of ranking album preferences of the forum as a whole. :)
     
  6. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Cheers!

    Perun, looking back, I also regret some grades (in most cases I wish I'd given a higher one).
    I hope we can change this, sooner or later, and all results will be adapted as well.

    Don't forget nush, who now and then has a habit of slaying a song with his grade even if his comments are pretty positive.

    Sometimes it's not easy to see if someone is conservative. It could be that someone really likes a song or album less than most others. Sometimes we can notice interesting developments. E.g. I've noticed that LooseCannon was a bit negative about POM beforehand, and when you see the final ranking it's not that terrible at all.

    I had a huh?-moment myself when I saw that the first album has the same grade as Piece of Mind. The first album is less produced, the lyrics less mature, and some of my favourite musicians Nicko, Adrian and Bruce are not playing on it. The Trooper is not on it, a song which I've seen and enjoyed many times.

    But when I think longer about it, about the individual songs and the impression they make on me, then I can understand it better.

    Actually, when I started all this, I planned to do this myself (in a different manner but with the same intention), when the whole thing is done. I guess some people might be surprised that SIT is seen as better than Powerslave and most other albums. In the survivors the songs from this album never did that well, and in SMX infamous album elimation thread (was that the title?) SIT was gone soon. I guess that several people who enjoy SIT so much don't play such games as much as the ones who like it less. On the other hand, we're not done yet. These were "only" the 1980s. ;)
     
  7. Albie

    Albie Keeping an open eye on the Weeping Angels.

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I will get round to voting for the remaining tracks on Iron Maiden, Killers, The Number of the Beast, Powerslave and Somewhere in Time. I will start with the debut - I think I'm only one or two short on that one.
     
  8. Perun

    Perun Climbing like a monkey Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Let's not forget we all may have different criteria on how we assign the points. Myself, I'm keeping it all in the relation to other Maiden songs only, so it's pretty obvious that the worst Maiden song will get only one point. If we did a comparison with other music in general, most of my grades would be up there at 9 or 10, and that's pretty pointless, in my eyes.

    Also, I see a ten point scale as a five star scale with "half stars", i.e. 10 points equals 5 stars, 9 points is 5 1/2 and so on. That's just the rating I am most familiar with and the one I have in my head when voting. So if someone gives a song 5 points, in my heads that equals 2 1/2, which is still not all that bad.
     
  9. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I know everyone has its own criteria but even so, why would the worst song need to have one point?
    If you'd have a job as a reviewer, and you'd work for 10 years at RockHard, would you then also have to rate at least one album of your favourite band with a 1?

    Now this is pointless in my eyes but maybe I'm overseeing something important.

    Would you enlighten me this philosophy, (even if it's yours and not mine)?
     
  10. LooseCannon

    LooseCannon Yorktown-class aircraft carrier Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    If you're ranking only on a list of Iron Maiden songs, then you have to establish a scale, 1-10. It's how ranking stuff works.
     
  11. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I know that a 1 is an option. I respect it if people use that option.

    Still it's curious if a teacher would have to give one student a 1, only because has to give at least one 1 per year, or because that student is the worst student of the class.
     
  12. Perun

    Perun Climbing like a monkey Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    If I was a reviewer at Rock Hard, I was reviewing Iron Maiden albums in comparison to other albums by other bands. Here, I am reviewing Iron Maiden songs in comparison to other Iron Maiden songs. If I have a scale of 1-10, to me that means the best song gets 10, the worst one gets 1. Otherwise, there wouldn't need to be a single point option, and you could go on saying: "Every Maiden song scores at least 5 in comparison to all other music, so let's have the scale start at 5!"
     
  13. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Thanks.

    Am I right that:

    Your philosophy is that a 1 has to be the worst Maiden song, or the worst Maiden song has to get a 1, regardless of any set of criteria besides that philosophy itself, while
    I say: the lowest grade (of my choice, not necessarily a 1) has to be the worst Maiden song, or the worst Maiden song has to get the lowest grade (of my choice, not necessarily a 1).

    I do this because to me a 1 means: total crap shit

    Since there is no Maiden song total crap shit to me, I'm not going to give a 1.
    I swear I'd give a Maiden song a 1 if a song was total crap shit to me.

    And don't forget, I am also reviewing Iron Maiden songs in comparison to other Iron Maiden songs. But I don't forget the meaning of the grades.

    It's not that terrible. Look at my album rankings. I am not using your system and more than the half of my rankings are nearer to 8 instead of 9 and 10.
     
  14. Perun

    Perun Climbing like a monkey Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Yes.

    So apparently it's a naming issue. If you want to get closer to what I think, you can simply rename "1" with the name of your least favourite and "10" with the name of your favourite song and call it the "Iron Maiden Scale". Totally useless for comparisons with other scales such as the "Black Sabbath Scale" or the "Judas Priest Scale". Unless you work out a conversion formula, so in the end, The Apparition would score 5 on the "Black Sabbath Scale", for instance, and Heaven and Hell would still score 10 on the "Iron Maiden Scale".

    But, since saying "Lord of Light scores a Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner on the Iron Maiden Scale" is awkward, I settle for the scores LooseCannon is offering.
     
  15. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Sorry, I edited my previous post rather late. Hope it contributes to show the differences in our views.
     
  16. Dr. Eddies Wingman

    Dr. Eddies Wingman Brighter than thousand_suns

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I'm more in line with Forostar here. I give 10 to songs I love, and 1 to songs I think are awful. I actually think it would be more interesting if everyone did this, because then we'd see how different members rated their least favourite Maiden songs relative to really bad music. I have so far not gone below 4 and I probably won't either. There may be a few more fours, but not many.

    I mean, I thought the purpose of the poll was to see how much each individual song was appreciated by the members, not to find yet another way to rank Maiden songs relative to each other. That has been done to death. Thus, I find it more interesting to see how people rate Maiden songs relative to music in general.

    Perun states that he would probably give most Maiden songs 9 or 10 if seen in relation with music in general. Others might go much lower for their least favourite song (for example, I've done that).

    But first of all, I really think this choice should not be up to each voter, it should have been dictated by the poll's administrator (LooseCannon). As it is now, some rate the songs relative to music in general, others rate them relative to other Maiden songs only. Of course, with many voters for each song we'll still see the relative order between the songs becoming fairly accurate.

    Just my two cents.
     
  17. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    If that's the essence of all this, then it's indeed better if the criteria are absolute (the meaning of a grade is known and fixed). It's more understandable to see how someone values a song, or better: how that value represents the appreciation.

    That's a nice thought indeed.
     
  18. Invader

    Invader Ancient Mariner

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Nah, I think the reason is that Powerslave's most popular songs (Aces High, Rime, Powerslave) are held by most people to be better than Somewhere in Time's most popular songs (Alexander, Wasted Years, the title track maybe?), and the survivors promote individual songs, not albums.  However, SIT's least popular songs are still more popular than Powerslave's least popular songs, i.e. SIT is much more consistent.  Therefore, when you take the album averages, a lot of people get very similar scores for the two albums.  I didn't give a single 10 to a SIT song (I did for Powerslave, PoM, IM and TNOTB), yet it was clearly the highest in my ratings.
     
  19. Perun

    Perun Climbing like a monkey Staff Member

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    I am aware of the difference in our views, I just wanted to make mine a bit more clear so there would be no misunderstandings. :)

    I agree with Wingman when he says that the criteria of the poll should have been clear from the start. But I say let's wait till this is done and see what the end results tell us.
     
  20. Forostar

    Forostar Conjure the Death Star again

    Re: The 1980s - album rankings per person

    Good idea Per.

    @Invader: I gave 5 10's for SSOASS but it still doesn't have the highest album ranking. :)
     

Share This Page